12 12 Razgnevannyh Muzhchin
|
00:00:52 |
"Seek the truth |
00:00:56 |
but in the essence of life itself." |
00:00:59 |
B. Tosia |
00:02:16 |
"Members of the jury..." |
00:02:19 |
"...for three days..." |
00:02:22 |
"...gravity of the crime..." |
00:02:24 |
"...the defendant receive" |
00:02:27 |
"...prosecution's request that" |
00:02:30 |
"You are aware of the..." |
00:02:32 |
"Members of the jury..." |
00:02:33 |
"...stand the gravity..." |
00:02:35 |
"...to the testimony..." |
00:02:36 |
"lf you agree with the prosecution..." |
00:02:39 |
"...you must return a" |
00:02:42 |
"...or not..." |
00:02:46 |
"For 1 000 years..." |
00:02:48 |
"...the Russian people gave" |
00:02:51 |
"...on these broad expanses" |
00:02:54 |
"...united under the banner" |
00:02:56 |
"...find reasonable doubt..." |
00:03:00 |
"...criminal code..." |
00:03:01 |
"...must return a verdict..." |
00:03:02 |
"...now deliberate in private..." |
00:03:07 |
"...not limited by time..." |
00:03:11 |
"You are aware of the" |
00:03:14 |
"...that the defendant receive" |
00:03:20 |
"...deliberate and decide..." |
00:03:24 |
"...that the defendant receive" |
00:03:27 |
"...penalty allowed by law..." |
00:03:29 |
"...that your decision must be unanimous..." |
00:03:32 |
"...unanimous" |
00:03:35 |
"l do not have words to describe" |
00:03:39 |
"...in these moments..." |
00:03:40 |
"...maximum penalty allowed..." |
00:03:43 |
"...details of the case..." |
00:03:45 |
"lf you find reasonable doubt..." |
00:03:47 |
"...the defendant receive" |
00:03:50 |
"...you must return" |
00:03:55 |
"l remind you that" |
00:03:59 |
"...you must return a verdict of "guilty"" |
00:04:03 |
"...maximum penalty..." |
00:04:04 |
"...where you must decide..." |
00:04:06 |
"...case-related materials..." |
00:04:08 |
"... I repeat: The jury may request..." |
00:04:10 |
"lf you find reasonable doubt..." |
00:04:29 |
PEACE, LABOR, HAPPlNESS! |
00:04:37 |
GLORY TO |
00:04:55 |
Mama! |
00:04:57 |
Speak Russian! |
00:05:01 |
Speak Russian, Mama! |
00:05:04 |
Speak Russian, Mama! |
00:05:10 |
Speak Russian, Mama! |
00:05:21 |
Court is adjourned until |
00:05:27 |
All rise please. |
00:05:36 |
Hello? |
00:05:38 |
Hungry, dad? |
00:05:39 |
So far everything's fine. Yes. |
00:05:43 |
Those photographs |
00:05:48 |
I don't know. |
00:05:49 |
- Do I have to stay here? |
00:05:52 |
- But I told them everything. |
00:05:56 |
- OK, gentlemen... |
00:05:58 |
Please follow me. |
00:06:04 |
- What recess? |
00:06:06 |
Please keep up. Follow me. |
00:06:14 |
This way, please. Let's go. |
00:06:18 |
As you see, the work's not finished. |
00:06:21 |
The jury room's not ready, either. |
00:06:24 |
Remodeling makes it hard to work. |
00:06:30 |
You'll be done in 20 minutes. |
00:06:33 |
Now we're in the adjoining school building, |
00:06:37 |
A school by a courthouse |
00:06:41 |
Imagine the spring, the windows open... |
00:06:43 |
...a ball flies in and hits a witness |
00:06:47 |
An elderly woman, out cold. |
00:06:49 |
During the school vacation |
00:06:52 |
...we used the classrooms... |
00:06:55 |
Children! Children! |
00:06:57 |
Oh, Lord. Children. |
00:06:59 |
Children! |
00:07:02 |
Now we turn left. |
00:07:10 |
Some working conditions! |
00:07:14 |
They'll finish and it'll be |
00:07:21 |
One silly formality. |
00:07:23 |
You'll have to give me your phones, |
00:07:27 |
I'll keep my SlM, it's important. |
00:07:29 |
Hello, Vasia. |
00:07:31 |
My phone'll be off for 90 minutes. |
00:07:34 |
Tell the boss it's my civic duty. |
00:07:38 |
I'll be right here. |
00:07:40 |
If you need me for any reason... |
00:07:43 |
...there's a communication system. |
00:07:47 |
This is my little "know-how". |
00:07:50 |
That means "invention". |
00:07:53 |
I took it from my son's |
00:07:57 |
It really works. |
00:07:58 |
Watch, everyone. |
00:08:01 |
That's awful. |
00:08:05 |
You keep this. |
00:08:07 |
And if you need me, |
00:08:10 |
and I'll bring |
00:08:14 |
Here's where you'll be meeting. |
00:08:20 |
Go ahead. |
00:08:27 |
Hands... |
00:08:40 |
- They put us in a gym? |
00:08:50 |
Anyone know how long it takes |
00:08:54 |
In weather like this. |
00:08:57 |
At least an hour and a half. |
00:09:01 |
You're kidding. |
00:09:05 |
Come on, take a shot. |
00:09:08 |
- With this thing? |
00:09:11 |
- Go Spartak. |
00:09:19 |
- What was that? |
00:09:21 |
That's a medicine ball. |
00:09:25 |
That's an antique. |
00:09:27 |
- You mean the lamp? |
00:09:29 |
We had exactly the same kind |
00:09:32 |
- Kids use these? |
00:09:33 |
Do you know where the bathroom is? |
00:09:47 |
They're locking us in? |
00:09:50 |
They have to, those are the rules. |
00:10:03 |
Seen that? |
00:10:05 |
Why is it in there? |
00:10:08 |
- Maybe so the kids don't hurt it. |
00:10:12 |
Or vice versa, so they |
00:10:16 |
It could fall. |
00:10:18 |
A courthouse isn't... |
00:10:20 |
the best thing to have |
00:10:25 |
It won't fall. |
00:10:26 |
Even the piano's behind bars |
00:10:30 |
The bathroom. |
00:10:38 |
Smart, no? |
00:10:40 |
Why don't you have some? |
00:10:45 |
- What is it, cheese? |
00:10:48 |
Thanks. Thanks anyway. |
00:10:51 |
I have a business lunch |
00:10:54 |
Don't want to spoil my appetite. |
00:10:57 |
And this won't take very long, right? |
00:11:00 |
I doubt it. It's not that kind of case. |
00:11:06 |
I agree. |
00:11:08 |
We have |
00:11:11 |
a different kind of case. |
00:11:16 |
That's an antique. How quaint. |
00:11:21 |
I had it stashed away. |
00:11:23 |
I forgot and didn't |
00:11:26 |
I was so angry... |
00:11:33 |
Comrades... I mean... |
00:11:36 |
...gentlemen. Let's start. |
00:11:43 |
Yes, comrades, I mean, gentlemen, |
00:11:47 |
I don't have much time. |
00:11:49 |
You in a hurry? |
00:11:52 |
And how: My train's in an hour. |
00:11:55 |
This'll take an hour, max. |
00:11:58 |
This one's for the kids. |
00:12:02 |
Can anyone tell me... |
00:12:04 |
...what rhymes with "Julie"? |
00:12:08 |
- Julie - cruelly. |
00:12:12 |
- It's a beautiful girl named Julie. |
00:12:16 |
Here you go... |
00:12:18 |
Duly. |
00:12:22 |
O'Dooley. Fazooli. Babooli. |
00:12:26 |
Woolly. |
00:12:29 |
Truly. |
00:12:32 |
- Patchouli. |
00:12:34 |
Patchouli. Truly. |
00:12:36 |
Mamooli. Pap... |
00:12:41 |
Oh, God... |
00:12:47 |
- Is today the 12th? |
00:12:49 |
- Where's the TV? Over here? |
00:12:54 |
They're interviewing my mother. |
00:12:58 |
Is she a politician? An actress? |
00:13:01 |
- It doesn't work? |
00:13:04 |
What is this? That's it. |
00:13:12 |
It doesn't work. |
00:13:15 |
Our family has a TV company. |
00:13:20 |
My mother's the president. |
00:13:22 |
I'm the managing director. |
00:13:28 |
So you're an assistant producer. |
00:13:34 |
Must be a weak stomach... |
00:13:37 |
- Have you ever seen anything like this? |
00:13:40 |
Ever seen one like this? |
00:13:42 |
And she's still just a schoolgirl. |
00:13:46 |
I only saw ones this big |
00:13:50 |
- On a schoolgirl? |
00:13:53 |
My mother-in-law's were about this size. |
00:13:58 |
We buried her three months ago. |
00:14:01 |
Oh, jeez! |
00:14:03 |
"Schoolmates!" |
00:14:07 |
"Boys and girls!" |
00:14:09 |
- Look what I found. |
00:14:11 |
"We sing the same songs" |
00:14:14 |
"We read the same books" |
00:14:17 |
- Let me see. God. |
00:14:34 |
Forgive me. |
00:14:36 |
I'm sorry. |
00:14:39 |
I'm sorry. |
00:14:41 |
I lost my brother because |
00:14:49 |
He was 36! |
00:14:53 |
Oh, mama! |
00:14:56 |
I have seen from this junk. |
00:15:02 |
I'm sorry. |
00:15:19 |
Gentlemen of the jury... |
00:15:23 |
Who's leading this parade? |
00:15:25 |
- Yes, let's start. |
00:15:27 |
Actually, we do have to... |
00:15:31 |
...choose a chairman for our meeting, |
00:15:36 |
You seem to have some experience. |
00:15:42 |
The phone only connects |
00:15:47 |
If nobody objects... |
00:15:49 |
I'd be glad to. |
00:15:51 |
So, no need to vote on it, then? |
00:15:54 |
As you know, our decision |
00:15:59 |
And not subject to appeal. |
00:16:02 |
And so... Attention, please. |
00:16:06 |
...our vote has got to be unanimous. |
00:16:09 |
We know all that. |
00:16:12 |
Make a unanimous decision... |
00:16:16 |
We can each make comments one by one. |
00:16:21 |
- No, let's vote. |
00:16:23 |
- Let's vote now. |
00:16:26 |
- Then nobody objects if... |
00:16:29 |
So, we can... |
00:16:32 |
...vote by the usual show of hands, |
00:16:36 |
- No, by hands. |
00:16:38 |
- Let's vote. |
00:16:42 |
- Yes, yes. |
00:16:44 |
All in favor, please raise your hands. |
00:16:48 |
One question. |
00:16:51 |
- What? |
00:16:55 |
Guilty, of course. |
00:16:57 |
I thought it was "in favor" of voting. |
00:17:00 |
We're voting on whether he is guilty. |
00:17:03 |
I didn't understand, that's all. |
00:17:08 |
- He didn't know |
00:17:12 |
That vote didn't count. |
00:17:15 |
So... Put your hands down. |
00:17:17 |
So we're voting... |
00:17:21 |
...on whether the defendant is guilty. |
00:17:26 |
A raised hand means guilty. |
00:17:28 |
- Yes, yes. |
00:17:30 |
I just want to get it right. |
00:17:32 |
Don't you go to meetings? |
00:17:36 |
What? All the time. |
00:17:38 |
Workers of the world... |
00:17:40 |
- Let's vote, come on. |
00:17:42 |
Why are we voting on "guilty" first? |
00:17:45 |
What's the difference? |
00:17:49 |
No, we can do this however we like. |
00:17:53 |
Does it bother you? |
00:17:56 |
No, I thought it might be a rule. |
00:17:59 |
No, there's no rule about that. |
00:18:02 |
- Let's do it this way. |
00:18:06 |
OK. So we're voting on |
00:18:11 |
- Yes. |
00:18:13 |
- Unanimous. We're out of here. |
00:18:16 |
Please. There are rules. Wait |
00:18:20 |
Please take your seats. |
00:18:24 |
Now, who thinks the defendant - |
00:18:27 |
...is not guilty, please raise your hand. |
00:18:35 |
That's eleven... |
00:18:37 |
- Here |
00:18:40 |
Whoa! |
00:18:43 |
What did we just vote on? |
00:18:46 |
Did you hear that? Hello! |
00:18:49 |
All that racket distracted the man. |
00:18:52 |
We voted on whether that stinking |
00:18:56 |
...of the murder of his adoptive father, |
00:19:01 |
Didn't understand? |
00:19:02 |
The comrade didn't understand. |
00:19:05 |
- So let's vote again. |
00:19:11 |
There's no need. I get it now. |
00:19:15 |
Against convicting him. |
00:19:25 |
What do you mean "against"? |
00:19:29 |
You voted "for". |
00:19:33 |
And I voted "against". |
00:19:36 |
Why? |
00:19:37 |
Well, it was eleven "for"... |
00:19:42 |
...and one "against". |
00:19:46 |
But why? |
00:19:49 |
Why what? |
00:19:51 |
Why did you vote that way? |
00:19:55 |
Well, if I'd voted "for" |
00:20:01 |
...none "against". |
00:20:05 |
But that'd be good. |
00:20:09 |
Vote "for" and let's go home. |
00:20:12 |
I... It was too fast, somehow. |
00:20:15 |
It was too fast, you see. |
00:20:18 |
Fast? We listened to that judge talk |
00:20:23 |
No, well, yes, but... |
00:20:27 |
It scared me. |
00:20:30 |
...that was it. It was too fast. |
00:20:33 |
Fast is good. It was obvious, |
00:20:36 |
We all heard the witnesses. |
00:20:40 |
Well, yes. |
00:20:44 |
But we're talking about a human being. |
00:20:49 |
And we just put up our hands... |
00:20:52 |
...and that was it. |
00:20:57 |
What exactly do you want? |
00:21:06 |
I want... |
00:21:15 |
...well, to talk, at least. |
00:21:29 |
To talk. |
00:21:37 |
So talk. |
00:21:56 |
"Beyond reasonable doubt." |
00:22:02 |
Sorry. That's a term |
00:22:09 |
"Beyond reasonable doubt". |
00:22:12 |
It's just that, I studied at Harvard... |
00:22:16 |
...I studied management. |
00:22:21 |
Talking would make sense |
00:22:27 |
Did you hear that? Reasonable doubt. |
00:22:31 |
None. He killed him! It's a fact! |
00:22:34 |
The brutal murder of an ex-officer |
00:22:39 |
- Yeah. |
00:22:41 |
That guy went to Harvard, |
00:22:44 |
- Neither do we. Do you? |
00:22:47 |
Forgive me, please, and understand. |
00:22:50 |
I know he went to Harvard. |
00:22:53 |
Say you go to the market |
00:22:58 |
- I do? |
00:23:01 |
I go to the market and buy a melon. |
00:23:04 |
The salesman assures me |
00:23:10 |
...until I take it home... |
00:23:13 |
...and cut it open, |
00:23:18 |
But this isn't a watermelon. |
00:23:22 |
A watermelon you can just throw away. |
00:23:47 |
This is a human being |
00:23:49 |
If we all vote yes, |
00:23:54 |
And he'll never get out. |
00:23:59 |
Do you understand? Ne-ver! |
00:24:01 |
Just think about that word. |
00:24:05 |
He'll never get out. |
00:24:09 |
And he shouldn't. |
00:24:11 |
He's a killer. What should he get? |
00:24:15 |
A paid vacation to Thailand? |
00:24:18 |
He should be grateful |
00:24:23 |
Prison will put some sense into him. |
00:24:38 |
All right. |
00:24:46 |
All right. |
00:24:49 |
Fine. |
00:24:51 |
I don't want to keep you. |
00:24:53 |
Let's vote again |
00:24:58 |
...vote with everyone else. |
00:25:00 |
And let the boy's fate be what it will. |
00:25:03 |
At least I'll know I tried |
00:25:08 |
That's an interesting move. |
00:25:10 |
Essentially, you'll do |
00:25:16 |
but you'll still be able to believe that |
00:25:24 |
Yes. |
00:25:27 |
It looks that way. |
00:25:29 |
But I request a secret ballot. |
00:25:33 |
Why? |
00:25:36 |
Honestly? To stall for time. |
00:25:38 |
We have to get paper, pens. |
00:25:41 |
Also, people often vote... |
00:25:44 |
...just so they don't |
00:25:47 |
So I request that we vote |
00:25:52 |
Secret or not, it's obvious |
00:26:14 |
So, we have a proposal for |
00:26:18 |
- Does everyone agree? |
00:26:23 |
- With these? |
00:26:27 |
If we're ready to vote, |
00:26:31 |
Wait... |
00:26:34 |
Someone's missing. |
00:26:42 |
That gentleman went to the bathroom. |
00:26:49 |
- I saw him, honest. |
00:26:53 |
- He's an elderly man. |
00:26:56 |
He has to get there and pee, |
00:26:59 |
Then put all his equipment back in... |
00:27:04 |
The ballot box. Let's vote. |
00:27:23 |
I see you've done this before. |
00:27:25 |
Yeah. Retirement's boring. |
00:27:29 |
I sit at my dacha and paint watercolors. |
00:27:34 |
- You're an artist? |
00:27:38 |
I just paint watercolors as a hobby. |
00:27:46 |
Has everyone turned in their ballot? |
00:27:53 |
- Did you vote already? |
00:27:58 |
"With birth and urination, |
00:28:02 |
Don't worry, I'll be fast. |
00:28:04 |
What a great one-liner! |
00:28:11 |
- Thank you. |
00:28:20 |
Well... |
00:28:23 |
Let's count... |
00:28:28 |
"Guilty". |
00:28:33 |
"Guilty". |
00:28:37 |
"Guilty". |
00:28:41 |
"Guilty". |
00:28:46 |
"Guilty". |
00:28:50 |
"Guilty". |
00:28:55 |
"Guilty". |
00:29:00 |
"Guilty". |
00:29:04 |
"Guilty". |
00:29:10 |
"Not guilty". |
00:29:29 |
"Guilty". |
00:29:32 |
So, that's ten... |
00:29:35 |
...for "guilty," and one against. |
00:29:38 |
Two. |
00:29:41 |
Two. |
00:29:56 |
Two. For "not guilty". |
00:29:58 |
What? Two? |
00:30:00 |
Wait. That can't be. |
00:30:02 |
Let me check those ballots. |
00:30:05 |
There's no need. |
00:30:07 |
No need to check anything. |
00:30:09 |
I voted to find the young man |
00:30:15 |
What? |
00:30:18 |
5 minutes ago you voted |
00:30:21 |
At first it seemed clear. |
00:30:25 |
- And now it doesn't? |
00:30:29 |
But this man... |
00:30:32 |
...proposed that I take responsibility |
00:30:36 |
And you know, I began to think. |
00:30:40 |
About what? |
00:30:42 |
Excuse me, but I don't understand. |
00:30:46 |
Absolutely correct. |
00:30:48 |
I'm a Jew. 1 00 per cent Jewish. |
00:30:52 |
And like everyone, |
00:30:54 |
But I do have one virtue. |
00:30:58 |
Thoughtfulness. I treasure it. |
00:31:00 |
I became thoughtful and went off |
00:31:05 |
And you know, |
00:31:08 |
Why? |
00:31:09 |
The lawyer. |
00:31:12 |
- The lawyer what? |
00:31:16 |
Why be excited? |
00:31:20 |
I had the impression |
00:31:24 |
And he was right! |
00:31:27 |
Exactly. There was no reason. |
00:31:31 |
The boy is destitute, |
00:31:35 |
The face of a drunk, |
00:31:38 |
Is it because he's not Jewish? |
00:31:41 |
Drunk? Maybe, but honest. |
00:31:43 |
Didn't let a killer off the hook. |
00:31:46 |
You should pray after a hunch. |
00:31:48 |
1 0 adults had no hunch at all. |
00:31:50 |
- But you did. |
00:31:53 |
Exactly, a sudden hunch in the can. |
00:31:56 |
I think better in there. |
00:31:58 |
Everyone does. |
00:32:02 |
There are 1 0 of you and only 2 of us. |
00:32:07 |
But I am worried. |
00:32:09 |
I am worried, see. |
00:32:12 |
Because I see how you and your |
00:32:16 |
...are muddying an obvious case. |
00:32:18 |
You didn't like the lawyer, |
00:32:22 |
That's a typical Jewish move. |
00:32:26 |
That's enough. |
00:32:28 |
I didn't change my mind. |
00:32:32 |
No such thing as a half-Jew. |
00:32:35 |
Is that a good thing... |
00:32:38 |
...or a bad thing? |
00:32:40 |
Now you, my friend... |
00:32:48 |
...stay out of this |
00:32:53 |
1, 2, 3, 4, 5 |
00:33:42 |
Look how much Umar likes your present. |
00:33:50 |
Umar, come eat. |
00:34:10 |
OK, then. |
00:34:12 |
Listen, so you found... |
00:34:14 |
...a good, kind, naive person, |
00:34:19 |
- "Braids" |
00:34:21 |
- What rhymes with it? |
00:34:25 |
No, I'm absolutely sure |
00:34:30 |
You'll waste time, |
00:34:34 |
...about choosing watermelons |
00:34:38 |
I don't see why. |
00:34:40 |
You'll make us go over everything |
00:34:44 |
All the evidence |
00:34:48 |
...that you'll never disprove, |
00:34:53 |
Then that man'll go |
00:34:57 |
To think. He'll change his decision |
00:35:00 |
Believe me |
00:35:03 |
What I don't get is, |
00:35:07 |
To go over the witness statements again? |
00:35:13 |
You saw that monster sitting in court. |
00:35:18 |
You want to talk? |
00:35:21 |
Let's talk about how you think |
00:35:24 |
...who can't possibly be justified. |
00:35:27 |
How can you justify a monster |
00:35:32 |
And not just attacked... |
00:35:35 |
...but cut his father's throat like a sheep. |
00:35:38 |
He killed the man who took care of him... |
00:35:42 |
He butchered a man |
00:35:46 |
Not only that, |
00:35:49 |
Who saved him. |
00:35:52 |
For his pension or because |
00:35:57 |
I can't get my head around it. |
00:36:03 |
...in defense of that bastard. |
00:36:06 |
I don't think any of us could. |
00:36:08 |
I don't think you could. |
00:36:10 |
So then what's the point of |
00:36:22 |
Sorry. |
00:36:26 |
- I had a wife. |
00:36:29 |
Wait. I had a wife. I loved her. |
00:36:32 |
- He couldn't keep her... Like the rhyme. |
00:36:36 |
We had a tiny room |
00:36:40 |
We even ate dinner on the floor, |
00:36:44 |
I was a junior researcher |
00:36:50 |
I was developing one of my ideas. |
00:36:53 |
So my wife had to work three jobs... |
00:36:56 |
...so we could make ends meet. |
00:36:59 |
Long story short, I invented a new |
00:37:03 |
It's hard to explain. |
00:37:06 |
At work they congratulated me... |
00:37:10 |
...gave me a 50-ruble bonus |
00:37:13 |
So I went home... |
00:37:15 |
...with the result of three years" work: |
00:37:21 |
My wife gave me a look... |
00:37:24 |
...Iike you'd give... |
00:37:28 |
Then a large foreign company... |
00:37:31 |
...offered to buy my patent |
00:37:35 |
But I said no, I wanted it |
00:37:38 |
I offered it to various places. |
00:37:40 |
They said "It's great". |
00:37:45 |
I began to drink. |
00:37:48 |
I lost my job, my wife left me. |
00:37:51 |
I only cared about drinking. |
00:37:55 |
I was dead drunk from morning to night. |
00:38:01 |
One day I sensed I would die soon. |
00:38:04 |
And the thought even made me happy, |
00:38:10 |
All I wanted was for it to be soon. |
00:38:12 |
I began to look for death, I really did, |
00:38:16 |
I would fight with police, bother people |
00:38:22 |
I slept on the street, |
00:38:25 |
I was beaten to a pulp. |
00:38:27 |
But I'd pull through and |
00:38:30 |
At home I'd lick my wounds |
00:38:34 |
...crawl out again. |
00:38:36 |
My only fear was... |
00:38:38 |
...jumping under a train |
00:38:42 |
Don't know why, it just scared me. |
00:38:45 |
One day I was on a train, |
00:38:48 |
I was filthy, I stank. |
00:38:50 |
The train was full |
00:38:54 |
Yelling, cursing. |
00:38:56 |
But I looked at myself and I was glad. |
00:39:04 |
My only wish was |
00:39:09 |
...and toss me off the train |
00:39:16 |
But they all just sat silently. |
00:39:20 |
They looked away, but they sat silently. |
00:39:26 |
Except for one woman |
00:39:30 |
I heard the little girl say: |
00:39:33 |
"Mama, that man's crazy. |
00:39:38 |
But the woman said: |
00:39:49 |
He's just very, very sad". |
00:40:00 |
I sold my invention |
00:40:03 |
Today it's used in almost half |
00:40:09 |
I work there. |
00:40:14 |
The woman is now my wife |
00:40:18 |
We also have a son. |
00:40:21 |
He's 4 years old. |
00:40:26 |
Are you done? |
00:40:39 |
No, there's more. |
00:40:51 |
Maybe that kid should... |
00:40:54 |
...die in prison. |
00:40:57 |
Maybe that's his fate. Who knows? |
00:41:00 |
Me, I should have died in the gutter. |
00:41:07 |
Because one person, just one... |
00:41:10 |
...Iooked at me a little more closely... |
00:41:13 |
...than everyone else |
00:41:17 |
And didn't let me remain... |
00:41:20 |
...in my lonely wretchedness. |
00:41:26 |
Now I'm done. |
00:41:42 |
Well... |
00:41:46 |
That's a touching story of salvation, |
00:41:51 |
but it's your story. |
00:41:53 |
And you didn't kill anyone. |
00:41:57 |
But this is a story of murder |
00:42:05 |
Testimony from the old man |
00:42:09 |
...who heard arguing, |
00:42:14 |
The boy says he didn't kill |
00:42:17 |
What would he say? "l killed him"? |
00:42:21 |
- Then we wouldn't be here. |
00:42:24 |
He can barely express himself |
00:42:27 |
What? Enough already! |
00:42:30 |
What are you saying? Listen! |
00:42:32 |
I don't give a damn |
00:42:36 |
But excuse me. You're all adults. |
00:42:39 |
Shame on you! Look around! |
00:42:41 |
It's not our city anymore. |
00:42:44 |
Everything! The markets, casinos, |
00:42:48 |
Yesterday I tried to drive down |
00:42:52 |
Eight lanes! |
00:42:54 |
Full of their Bentley-shmentleys, |
00:42:57 |
It was some kind of wedding. |
00:43:00 |
Songs! Dancing! |
00:43:04 |
And this was a 3-minute walk |
00:43:08 |
This isn't Moscow anymore. |
00:43:12 |
And me, a native Muscovite, |
00:43:14 |
I feel like an alien in my own city. |
00:43:18 |
And the boy? |
00:43:20 |
You're trying to defend him, right? |
00:43:24 |
Remember how they said... |
00:43:26 |
...he argued with his father |
00:43:29 |
Imagine a Russian kid. |
00:43:33 |
He might get angry, curse him out... |
00:43:36 |
...maybe run away. |
00:43:38 |
But he wouldn't pick up a knife. |
00:43:41 |
But that savage, your boy, |
00:43:43 |
...he'd hide his anger and then go back |
00:43:49 |
I've heard enough. |
00:43:51 |
Savage? We live in the 21 st century, |
00:43:54 |
And there's no need to exaggerate. |
00:43:58 |
It's an enormous job we're doing. |
00:44:00 |
We? Who's we? Who? Who's we? |
00:44:05 |
- Democratic forces. |
00:44:08 |
What kind of forces? |
00:44:11 |
I agree. |
00:44:13 |
I'm not talking about that, I mean... |
00:44:17 |
They're bastards. Bastards. |
00:44:21 |
One on one they're OK, |
00:44:25 |
One time I was on a train, on vacation. |
00:44:29 |
Four of those animals, one with a knife. |
00:44:32 |
They robbed me. |
00:44:35 |
and one went through my pockets. |
00:44:38 |
I wasn't really scared, |
00:44:45 |
One gassed me, right in the nose. |
00:44:49 |
I came to in Simferopol. |
00:44:51 |
Later, I saw 2 of them |
00:44:55 |
They recognized me... |
00:44:57 |
...and started to lick my sandals. |
00:45:01 |
Our people surrounded them. |
00:45:03 |
I was disgusted. I grabbed them |
00:45:08 |
I kicked them in the ass. |
00:45:11 |
I twisted my ankle and |
00:45:16 |
And now I have pain in my groin. |
00:45:20 |
- I'm a surgeon. |
00:45:24 |
I don't need a surgeon yet, |
00:45:28 |
They're bastards. |
00:45:37 |
If he didn't kill him, what difference |
00:45:42 |
...esteemed gentlemen of the jury? |
00:45:49 |
That's right. |
00:46:47 |
Do you like it? |
00:46:49 |
Yeah. |
00:46:51 |
Look how pretty it is. |
00:46:57 |
Thanks. |
00:48:19 |
Umar! |
00:48:24 |
Go home! |
00:48:26 |
Go home and do your homework. |
00:48:29 |
Sorry, my father's calling me. |
00:48:33 |
Don't worry. You'll get your chance |
00:48:40 |
Hey, friend, |
00:48:44 |
What'd you say, friend? |
00:48:49 |
We'll deal with this at home |
00:48:51 |
Volodya, go home. Umar. |
00:48:56 |
Come here, little wolf. |
00:49:01 |
Let's go. |
00:49:13 |
He who has hidden his head under his wife's |
00:49:36 |
1, 2, 3, 4, 5. |
00:50:08 |
By the way, I asked them to bring |
00:50:12 |
Why? |
00:50:14 |
In court they kept stressing that |
00:50:21 |
And that... |
00:50:25 |
Thank you. |
00:50:27 |
And that only that kid had one. |
00:50:33 |
You remember? |
00:50:35 |
In court they kept saying that it was... |
00:50:39 |
...a unique knife. |
00:50:42 |
Special. |
00:50:45 |
Here. |
00:50:48 |
Let me see. |
00:50:54 |
Yeah. This is a specialized knife. |
00:50:58 |
Used by some units |
00:51:03 |
Similar to the American model |
00:51:08 |
Made by Ernst Emerson. |
00:51:11 |
It's monogrammed. |
00:51:13 |
The kid could've brought this knife |
00:51:17 |
They're black market there. |
00:51:19 |
You can't buy a knife like this |
00:51:24 |
This knife has devastating |
00:51:30 |
Oh my! |
00:52:33 |
PAPA |
00:52:40 |
It's that... |
00:52:42 |
A major in the special forces. |
00:52:45 |
His unit was fighting in the area |
00:52:50 |
Later he adopted him. |
00:52:53 |
Did you lose something? |
00:52:55 |
- Hey, what if... |
00:52:57 |
Those soldiers were the ones |
00:53:01 |
That's motive. Motive for murder. |
00:53:05 |
Yes, but he had known the boy |
00:53:09 |
...and was a family friend. |
00:53:11 |
What about the knife. |
00:53:14 |
There are initials on it. |
00:53:16 |
No, the initials don't match |
00:53:20 |
It's a rare knife. It was kept at home. |
00:53:23 |
The kid carried it with him all the time. |
00:53:26 |
His friends saw him with it. |
00:53:30 |
They kept saying it was |
00:53:34 |
Special. |
00:53:36 |
Just listen to what you're suggesting. |
00:53:39 |
What is it? |
00:53:40 |
- Can't find it. |
00:53:43 |
Just walking, walking... |
00:53:45 |
And suddenly some guy |
00:53:51 |
"Hey kid, do you happen to know |
00:53:56 |
And he says: "Why, yes! I have |
00:54:01 |
Rare. Unique. Yes". |
00:54:04 |
And he sells it to him. Yes. |
00:54:05 |
The boy sold him this knife. The man |
00:54:11 |
It's totally lun-icrous! |
00:54:15 |
- What? |
00:54:18 |
Wait, wait! |
00:54:20 |
What about the money? |
00:54:22 |
They found 7 thousand in his pocket! |
00:54:26 |
The same exact amount as... |
00:54:28 |
...the pension the father received that day. |
00:54:33 |
He killed him and robbed him. |
00:54:36 |
There's no sense in listening |
00:54:39 |
- You can't get another knife like that, guys. |
00:54:43 |
Thank God. The key is tiny, |
00:54:47 |
But it was hiding |
00:54:51 |
I also thought that the knife |
00:54:57 |
And that only he had one. |
00:55:00 |
Look. |
00:55:02 |
Here. |
00:55:11 |
One and the same. |
00:55:13 |
With a receipt. |
00:55:18 |
They said it's unique, special |
00:55:22 |
At the "Extreme" market |
00:55:36 |
So what's that prove? |
00:55:38 |
That the Chechen |
00:55:41 |
No, it proves nothing. |
00:55:43 |
Why not? We're locked in. |
00:55:46 |
- Ashtray. |
00:55:48 |
- Thanks. I had a different goal. |
00:55:52 |
- Bought it. |
00:55:55 |
These days you can even buy |
00:55:59 |
But can you tell me how that proves... |
00:56:02 |
...that the man who bought the knife |
00:56:06 |
May l? It doesn't prove that at all. |
00:56:12 |
Thank you. |
00:56:13 |
I'm saying that the uniqueness |
00:56:16 |
...the prosecution's main argument. |
00:56:19 |
But it turns out you can buy one easily. |
00:56:22 |
So what? What does that mean? |
00:56:25 |
It means the investigation wasn't very |
00:56:30 |
The lawyer. The lawyer. He had nothing to say. |
00:56:35 |
He couldn't defend him. |
00:56:38 |
What...? What if... |
00:56:41 |
...the one who bought it is the killer? |
00:56:44 |
Oh, Jesus! |
00:56:46 |
Buddy, why do you have |
00:56:50 |
Someone bought it and killed him. |
00:56:53 |
Do you even understand |
00:56:56 |
Five minutes ago you drew us |
00:56:59 |
"He killed and robbed him". |
00:57:03 |
...to kill a major for his pension? |
00:57:06 |
If I were you I'd listen to the comrade |
00:57:10 |
You know, your reasoning is somehow... |
00:57:14 |
Jewish. |
00:57:15 |
What, I should reason |
00:57:19 |
All right. No, well... |
00:57:22 |
OK. So the working guy |
00:57:26 |
- Why are you supporting him? |
00:57:31 |
See, that's a typical Jewish trick. |
00:57:34 |
If a non-Jew says something stupid, |
00:57:38 |
...if it's a Jew, it's not stupid. |
00:57:41 |
All right. |
00:57:42 |
The knife, a coincidence. It's the same, |
00:57:46 |
used it to kill the father. |
00:57:50 |
Is that also a coincidence? |
00:57:53 |
2 coincidences in a row? |
00:57:56 |
It never happens. Never. |
00:57:58 |
You know, for some time now |
00:58:04 |
...anything is possible in life. |
00:58:08 |
My dad... |
00:58:12 |
...was in the ghetto during the War. |
00:58:14 |
- A Holocaust story? |
00:58:17 |
The headquarters of the |
00:58:22 |
And there was an SS officer there |
00:58:27 |
Now, my dad was a scrawny man. |
00:58:32 |
You see what I look like? |
00:58:36 |
And did you inherit your dad's looks? |
00:58:40 |
No, my mom's. Mom was no beauty, |
00:58:44 |
It made it that much easier |
00:58:48 |
My father fell in love with that |
00:58:52 |
And she fell in love with my father, |
00:58:58 |
Imagine what would've happened |
00:59:02 |
The SS officer fled to Germany. |
00:59:05 |
And she stayed with my dad. |
00:59:09 |
Oh, God, wow! |
00:59:11 |
They were both arrested |
00:59:15 |
They were released in 1 953, |
00:59:19 |
They moved to a little farm |
00:59:22 |
...and began to crank out children. |
00:59:27 |
By this time, of course, my dad had been |
00:59:32 |
But I understand him. |
00:59:35 |
For one thing... |
00:59:37 |
...I saw her photograph. |
00:59:46 |
I saw her photograph. |
00:59:52 |
And for another... |
00:59:56 |
...my mother was no angel, either. |
01:00:01 |
Mother was no angel. |
01:00:08 |
An amazing story. |
01:00:13 |
If someone told me a story like that, |
01:00:21 |
But it happened to my dad. |
01:00:24 |
Anything can happen. |
01:00:27 |
Anything. |
01:01:07 |
Stop, stop. I have doubts. |
01:01:12 |
And we hold the shovel in our own. |
01:01:16 |
Well... If you only knew. |
01:01:20 |
He lives near Voronezh, he's a plumber. |
01:01:25 |
Hands of gold! |
01:01:27 |
He's generous and kind. |
01:01:32 |
He likes to drink, |
01:01:36 |
He doesn't drink too often. |
01:01:40 |
In the center of town |
01:01:42 |
there's a square. |
01:01:45 |
They built this place there where |
01:01:50 |
"Brother," it's called. "Brother". |
01:01:52 |
Uncle Kolya had never been a gambler. |
01:01:58 |
And went there. |
01:02:00 |
And, well, he lost. |
01:02:05 |
He lost every cent. |
01:02:08 |
He thinks: "How can I go home now |
01:02:11 |
to Liuba, to my wife, and say: |
01:02:14 |
"Liuba, I lost everything, all the money". |
01:02:18 |
It'd be easier to hang himself. |
01:02:21 |
But some kind people told him: |
01:02:24 |
"There's a place nearby |
01:02:28 |
So he goes there and they say: |
01:02:33 |
but with high interest, |
01:02:39 |
So if you want 50 thousand, you got it, |
01:02:44 |
What could he do? |
01:02:46 |
He takes the 50 thousand... |
01:02:49 |
...and goes back to that |
01:02:54 |
And he... |
01:02:56 |
He loses it all. |
01:02:59 |
The whole 50 thousand. |
00:00:12 |
Middle of the day. |
00:00:16 |
He goes to work, tells the boss: |
00:00:19 |
"Give me 50 thousand". |
00:00:22 |
"Nuts, eh? Just you wait." |
00:00:26 |
And goes back. By this time |
00:00:30 |
He goes to the accounting office. |
00:00:33 |
He takes three of them hostage. |
00:00:37 |
He becomes a terrorist. |
00:00:41 |
He makes them put |
00:00:45 |
his demands - |
00:00:49 |
a luxury apartment, |
00:00:54 |
and a plane to anywhere on earth |
00:00:58 |
Now, why did he ask for a job, |
00:01:01 |
when he planned to fly off in a plane? |
00:01:04 |
That's not important. |
00:01:08 |
The women say: "Uncle Kolya, |
00:01:12 |
But he just goes "oooo!" |
00:01:15 |
The women open the safe |
00:01:19 |
One goes to buy vodka, |
00:01:22 |
And the police are there, snipers. |
00:01:25 |
"He's a terrorist! Get him! Fire!" |
00:01:28 |
But the police chief says: |
00:01:33 |
I'll go myself!" |
00:01:35 |
And he goes in unarmed. What a man! |
00:01:38 |
Uncle Kolya points the gun at him: |
00:01:40 |
And the chief says: "No you won't". |
00:01:43 |
"Why not?" |
00:01:47 |
Uncle Kolya drops the shotgun. |
00:01:51 |
They sit around the case of vodka. |
00:01:56 |
They have a drink. |
00:01:58 |
And cry. |
00:02:01 |
And there was no trial, no investigation. |
00:02:18 |
I beg your pardon, but why exactly |
00:02:23 |
Why? He could have been sent to prison, |
00:02:28 |
or shot. A terrorist! |
00:02:30 |
But the police chief, what a man. |
00:02:34 |
Uncle Kolya worked and paid off his debt. |
00:02:38 |
The police chief moved up. |
00:02:42 |
And "Brother" was burned down. |
00:02:45 |
But by someone else, |
00:02:48 |
That's wonderful. |
00:02:50 |
But what does all that have to do |
00:02:56 |
Lf... if... |
00:03:00 |
I'm for kindness. |
00:03:02 |
Your brains sure curdled fast, brother. |
00:03:05 |
No, no. |
00:03:09 |
A good man should be helped. |
00:03:12 |
And a bad man should be... |
00:03:17 |
I vote that the young Chechen |
00:03:20 |
Write it down. Thank you. |
00:03:23 |
Well! |
00:03:25 |
That's amazing! |
00:03:28 |
What kind of justice is that? |
00:03:31 |
Uncle Kolya the plumber |
00:03:34 |
Uncle Lyosha the police chief |
00:03:38 |
Uncle Vasya the city prosecutor |
00:03:42 |
And the criminal remains at large! |
00:03:47 |
And meanwhile the entire |
00:03:50 |
has lived for centuries |
00:03:57 |
A Russian man will |
00:04:00 |
- Why not? |
00:04:05 |
The law is dead. |
00:04:07 |
There's nothing personal about it. |
00:04:10 |
And a Russian man without that |
00:04:14 |
He won't steal or guard. |
00:04:16 |
But that's awful! |
00:04:18 |
Who said it was good? |
00:04:20 |
Look at that horrible pipe. |
00:04:24 |
It's obscene. |
00:04:25 |
Total filth in the center of Moscow. |
00:04:28 |
In a school, |
00:04:31 |
The builders forgot to run |
00:04:34 |
and then the school was built. |
00:04:37 |
They should cut off their limbs |
00:04:40 |
By law. |
00:04:42 |
But there are personal ties. |
00:04:47 |
The school let them temporarily |
00:04:52 |
And it has a corrosive effect |
00:04:57 |
Maybe that's why they leave |
00:05:00 |
And nobody gets steamed up. |
00:05:03 |
What's the law got to do with it? |
00:05:06 |
Human relations. |
00:05:09 |
Here! You'll love this. |
00:05:16 |
Inventory number 72-1 7-99. |
00:05:20 |
Young Eagle Pioneer Camp. |
00:05:22 |
1 967. |
00:05:25 |
I wasn't even born then. |
00:05:28 |
Do you see how it is? |
00:05:31 |
40 years have passed. 40 years! |
00:05:33 |
And we still can't wake up |
00:05:37 |
4 decades of running in place. |
00:05:43 |
That's it. I missed my train. |
00:05:47 |
But I'm here. And I'm voting. |
00:05:51 |
The young Chechen is not guilty. |
00:05:55 |
Write it down. Period. |
00:05:58 |
Shit... |
00:05:59 |
What are you...? Aw, hell! |
00:06:03 |
- This is a circus? |
00:06:07 |
Let's all join them! |
00:06:10 |
- Wonderful... |
00:06:15 |
And, incidentally, |
00:06:20 |
Can you explain why |
00:06:24 |
if he killed and robbed |
00:06:28 |
...he returned with the money |
00:06:33 |
Yes, good point. |
00:06:35 |
Atypical murderer wouldn't do that. |
00:06:38 |
Listen, just listen. |
00:06:41 |
OK, you're a respectable man, |
00:06:44 |
How can you say that? |
00:06:48 |
Atypical one wouldn't go back, |
00:06:51 |
because he's a stupid, |
00:06:54 |
who just jumped out of the tree. |
00:06:57 |
You expect him to write novels? |
00:07:00 |
You know perfectly well, |
00:07:03 |
My dear sir... |
00:07:05 |
...excuse me, but just who |
00:07:08 |
I'm also from the Caucasus, |
00:07:11 |
So the poet Rustaveli was a savage? |
00:07:14 |
The artist Pirosmani? |
00:07:18 |
- Who's a savage? |
00:07:21 |
I'm talking about the monster |
00:07:25 |
I'm talking about myself. |
00:07:27 |
I'm also from the Caucasus. |
00:07:30 |
But I get called "monkey". |
00:07:34 |
A physician. I have my own clinic. |
00:07:38 |
I don't doubt it, OK, so you're not |
00:07:43 |
Then why do people come here |
00:07:48 |
What? To buy what? |
00:07:50 |
- I bought one? |
00:07:53 |
I'm asking you, wait! |
00:07:57 |
I never paid anyone |
00:08:01 |
How dare you? |
00:08:04 |
I tried 4 times before I got into |
00:08:08 |
And for all 4 years I worked |
00:08:14 |
I worked as a paramedic and in the ER. |
00:08:19 |
Yes, |
00:08:23 |
So what? |
00:08:26 |
So what? I apologized. |
00:08:30 |
I don't doubt that you're a good doctor. |
00:08:33 |
a good doctor like you |
00:08:36 |
if everyone in the Caucasus |
00:08:40 |
That's why I voted guilty. |
00:08:42 |
It's an unheard of affront |
00:08:46 |
to raise a hand against an elder. |
00:08:49 |
Especially if he took you |
00:08:53 |
Brothers, brothers... |
00:08:55 |
Gentlemen... Comrades... |
00:08:57 |
Come on, let's be civilized. |
00:09:00 |
I'm over here writing, plus one, |
00:09:03 |
...Iet's be civilized, let's do it again. |
00:09:06 |
Let's all vote calmly. |
00:09:10 |
- So let's vote, OK? |
00:09:13 |
Now. Who votes |
00:09:15 |
to find the accused not guilty? |
00:09:21 |
Not guilty. Please pay attention. |
00:09:25 |
One, |
00:09:27 |
two, three, four, |
00:09:31 |
five. |
00:09:33 |
Who votes to find the defendant guilty? |
00:09:37 |
One, two, three, four, five, |
00:09:41 |
six... |
00:09:43 |
Seven. |
00:09:45 |
Seven "for"... |
00:09:47 |
Five for "not guilty", |
00:11:52 |
The boundary is here, right? |
00:11:56 |
Let's reproduce it. |
00:11:58 |
So your amateur theatre is going to |
00:12:03 |
Exactly? No, how could we? |
00:12:08 |
We'll try to mirror-image them, |
00:12:12 |
Listen, the old man downstairs heard |
00:12:17 |
And a falling body |
00:12:21 |
Have any of you been |
00:12:26 |
Of course not. |
00:12:28 |
You know, I have... |
00:12:32 |
because I was curious to see |
00:12:34 |
a building where only two apartments |
00:12:39 |
In one, a murder, in the other, |
00:12:43 |
And nobody else. |
00:12:44 |
What's that got to do |
00:12:48 |
Next to the building |
00:12:51 |
They're building luxury apartments. |
00:12:55 |
- They work around the clock. |
00:12:59 |
Imagine the noise |
00:13:04 |
Your point? |
00:13:06 |
The old man claims he heard |
00:13:09 |
and then he heard something fall, |
00:13:14 |
Yeah, so? What? What? |
00:13:16 |
With all due respect to the witness, |
00:13:22 |
Wait. One second. |
00:13:25 |
that the old man knowingly lied in court, |
00:13:29 |
An old-school communist |
00:13:31 |
slandered an innocent Chechen boy |
00:13:35 |
If anyone lied, under oath and otherwise, |
00:13:40 |
They lied from top to bottom, |
00:13:44 |
For privileges, for power, |
00:13:48 |
Let's not talk about that, please. |
00:13:51 |
Some people were different. |
00:13:53 |
My father was a regional party secretary |
00:13:56 |
Privileges? What privileges? |
00:14:00 |
Sometimes we didn't see him for years. |
00:14:04 |
After he retired, |
00:14:07 |
They spit him out like old gum. |
00:14:11 |
How do you think it looks? |
00:14:15 |
- Pretty close. |
00:14:17 |
Now, we've created two identical |
00:14:21 |
As I said, one's on top of the other, |
00:14:26 |
In his testimony the old man said |
00:14:29 |
that at the time of the crime |
00:14:33 |
...on the living room sofa... |
00:14:37 |
I'll ask the bailiff. |
00:14:45 |
What's that? |
00:14:47 |
The train. I'll call you back. |
00:14:58 |
Oh Lord! |
00:15:03 |
- You rang? |
00:15:06 |
We need to read. It's an experiment. |
00:15:09 |
It's nighttime. |
00:15:13 |
All right, I'll turn it on. |
00:15:25 |
You'll have light. |
00:15:28 |
Yeltsin's fault. |
00:15:33 |
Thank you. |
00:15:35 |
Thank you, Boris. |
00:15:36 |
The old man was lying right here |
00:15:39 |
The crime happened here. |
00:15:41 |
He said his living room is |
00:15:45 |
Did anyone notice how the old man |
00:15:49 |
Yes, I remember very well! |
00:15:54 |
Because he has arthritis. |
00:15:56 |
The floor plan shows |
00:15:59 |
And we've reproduced them almost exactly, |
00:16:05 |
to see he had to get up from the sofa, |
00:16:07 |
walk 35 meters, open the door, |
00:16:11 |
and still manage to see someone. |
00:16:14 |
- Anyone know average walking speed? |
00:16:18 |
- A meter and a half. |
00:16:21 |
So, 1 0 seconds is 1 5 meters. |
00:16:24 |
So 35 meters is about 25 seconds. |
00:16:26 |
And we'll see which one of us |
00:16:31 |
But you have to walk like him. |
00:16:35 |
Pardon me, gentlemen. |
00:16:39 |
- Yes. |
00:16:40 |
Thank you, as well. |
00:16:43 |
You're the old man on the sofa. |
00:16:45 |
It should take you 2 seconds |
00:16:50 |
Start when I say so. |
00:16:53 |
- Action! |
00:16:58 |
- What's going on? |
00:17:01 |
- Excuse me, you're disturbing us. |
00:17:05 |
No problem. Thank you. |
00:17:16 |
It's OK. Start again. |
00:17:18 |
Reset the clock to zero. |
00:17:20 |
Zero. |
00:17:22 |
- Ready? |
00:17:23 |
Attention... |
00:17:27 |
- Action! |
00:17:31 |
- Get up. |
00:17:33 |
The knife. There are prints. |
00:17:35 |
Come on, old man, up! |
00:17:37 |
You hear a noise. |
00:17:39 |
No, wait. |
00:17:43 |
Wipe off the fingerprints completely. |
00:17:45 |
Come on, old man, come on. |
00:17:48 |
I wipe off the fingerprints. |
00:17:51 |
You have to take the money. |
00:17:54 |
Old man, come on, come on, let's go! |
00:17:57 |
Let's go! |
00:17:58 |
But the boy would know |
00:18:03 |
OK, I look for the money. |
00:18:06 |
I think that's enough time |
00:18:09 |
Don't forget, put on your coat. |
00:18:10 |
Come on, old man, something's up, |
00:18:14 |
- Someone's shouting. |
00:18:16 |
I put on my jacket. I button it. I walk. |
00:18:21 |
I walk. I'm in the other room now. |
00:18:25 |
I open the door, I run. |
00:18:27 |
I open another door. |
00:18:33 |
I open the door. I'm on the stairs. |
00:18:36 |
Seven stairs, |
00:18:40 |
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7. |
00:18:44 |
The old man's apartment |
00:18:51 |
I'm outside! |
00:18:57 |
But he only got as far as the door. |
00:18:59 |
Add another 5 seconds for him |
00:19:03 |
53 seconds, gentlemen. |
00:19:10 |
53 seconds. |
00:19:22 |
So what? |
00:19:26 |
Maybe it was like that. |
00:19:29 |
And maybe it wasn't. |
00:19:33 |
The police believed the old man. |
00:19:36 |
And I believe the police. |
00:19:41 |
Or someone else running away. |
00:19:44 |
Who? |
00:19:47 |
Someone who wasn't in a hurry. |
00:19:49 |
Someone who needed to be seen. |
00:19:54 |
Push up. |
00:19:58 |
You know, I think... |
00:20:01 |
...that an old man with |
00:20:05 |
could never walk |
00:20:09 |
I say that as a doctor. |
00:20:12 |
I want to vote. |
00:20:15 |
I vote that the boy is not guilty. |
00:20:19 |
Six - six. |
00:20:21 |
And... |
00:20:24 |
Me too. |
00:20:28 |
Seven -five. |
00:20:36 |
Seven -five. |
00:22:19 |
- What is it? |
00:22:22 |
Cold? We're all cold, pal. |
00:22:25 |
They gave you double bars. |
00:22:29 |
Deal with it, pal. |
00:22:57 |
"A birch, a rowan tree" |
00:23:02 |
"A willow on the river bank" |
00:23:07 |
So, actor... |
00:23:08 |
Your squad went to earn |
00:23:11 |
We call it "cleaning up". |
00:23:14 |
"-Where could you find..." |
00:23:17 |
- For free, though. |
00:23:23 |
Did you switch sides as a joke? |
00:23:27 |
That's called "buffoonery". |
00:23:32 |
You... Hey. Sorry, l... |
00:23:38 |
I didn't mean to. |
00:23:43 |
Listen... |
00:23:49 |
Listen. |
00:23:50 |
Listen, you. |
00:23:54 |
Why are you always |
00:23:57 |
I said sorry. OK... |
00:23:58 |
Why do you do it? |
00:24:01 |
Did we play football... |
00:24:03 |
...or drink vodka or chase girls? |
00:24:05 |
- What? Huh? |
00:24:08 |
- Who cackles? |
00:24:11 |
- Who cackles? |
00:24:14 |
Why would I cackle? |
00:24:17 |
You found yourself a clown, eh? |
00:24:19 |
What am l, a clown to you? |
00:24:23 |
I'm sick of your laughter! |
00:24:25 |
You've all turned blue from cackling, |
00:24:29 |
You always want to laugh. |
00:24:31 |
You think it's funny. |
00:24:36 |
Before you even sit in your seat |
00:24:41 |
You laugh at absolutely everything! |
00:24:43 |
Life. Death. Tsunami. |
00:24:46 |
Earthquakes! And you cackle! |
00:24:49 |
Half the country's freezing... |
00:24:51 |
A cop murders someone... |
00:24:58 |
Why are you laughing? |
00:25:01 |
Because being serious terrifies you. |
00:25:05 |
Not long ago... |
00:25:08 |
...I was performing and I started |
00:25:13 |
About my life, |
00:25:16 |
Everyone laughed. |
00:25:18 |
They thought it was a joke. |
00:25:22 |
I bet if I were to spit |
00:25:25 |
from the stage onto the first row, |
00:25:28 |
they'd still laugh, |
00:25:35 |
Found yourself a clown? |
00:25:38 |
I'm no clown. |
00:25:40 |
I've only really earned one smile. |
00:25:44 |
One single smile. |
00:25:48 |
When I was playing that old man. |
00:25:55 |
As a kid, I stayed alone a lot |
00:26:02 |
I was five or six, yeah, six. |
00:26:06 |
She collapsed. |
00:26:12 |
I called an ambulance, |
00:26:16 |
I gave her medicine. |
00:26:20 |
I was terrified. |
00:26:23 |
She was my grandmother, after all. |
00:26:26 |
I decided to cheer her up. |
00:26:29 |
I started imitating |
00:26:31 |
and another friend of hers. |
00:26:35 |
Grandma was in a lot of pain |
00:26:43 |
Even when they were carrying her body |
00:26:51 |
All that... |
00:26:54 |
...Iaughter... |
00:26:58 |
...and a smile. |
00:27:06 |
And that Chechen kid... |
00:27:11 |
The old man... |
00:27:16 |
I could feel in my bones... |
00:27:20 |
...their horrible fear... |
00:27:24 |
...and loneliness. |
00:27:26 |
Same as when I was with my grandmother |
00:27:34 |
That was the only smile |
00:27:37 |
I ever really earned. |
00:27:41 |
Good thing there are mats. |
00:27:43 |
I could've broken my back. |
00:28:18 |
What a Russian story. |
00:28:27 |
Yeah. |
00:28:29 |
Everything here is very Russian somehow. |
00:28:34 |
Yes. It's not Harvard. |
00:28:38 |
Really got to you, huh? |
00:28:42 |
Hey, let's do one more experiment. |
00:28:45 |
You did an experiment. |
00:28:52 |
Now, just imagine... |
00:28:55 |
You have an imagination, right? |
00:28:57 |
Me? |
00:28:58 |
It's not bad. It's... |
00:29:02 |
Naturally! Yeah! |
00:29:05 |
...you're coming home. |
00:29:08 |
Late at night. |
00:29:10 |
- Are you married? |
00:29:13 |
Hold this, please. |
00:29:14 |
- Do you have kids? |
00:29:17 |
- What kind of car? |
00:29:21 |
So, imagine that you're coming home |
00:29:25 |
You live in a good area, |
00:29:28 |
With a concierge, security cameras, |
00:29:32 |
secure parking lot, |
00:29:37 |
I have a keychain alarm. |
00:29:38 |
Kolya the guard... |
00:29:41 |
His name is Kolya. |
00:29:43 |
Uncle Petya the custodian. |
00:29:45 |
- Uncle Valera. |
00:29:47 |
- Hi, Uncle Valera. |
00:29:51 |
You're not afraid. |
00:29:53 |
It's your home. |
00:29:55 |
Your very well-guarded home. |
00:29:57 |
And so, you park your wheels |
00:30:01 |
and suddenly you notice |
00:30:04 |
- What's wrong? |
00:30:07 |
They're usually asleep by now, |
00:30:11 |
So? Maybe they waited up. |
00:30:13 |
Of course. |
00:30:16 |
But there's a noise |
00:30:19 |
"Everything OK?" |
00:30:22 |
He says: "Yes, it's fine". |
00:30:24 |
You go in. |
00:30:27 |
Everything's fine. |
00:30:29 |
Just listen. |
00:30:33 |
You go to the elevator. |
00:30:36 |
Right. How did you know? |
00:30:41 |
Of course you do. |
00:30:44 |
It's the best one. |
00:30:47 |
And it has a good view. |
00:30:49 |
But why aren't they asleep? |
00:30:51 |
Why? You'll see the surprise |
00:30:55 |
Here it is, fifth floor. "Fifth floor". |
00:30:59 |
It's a woman's voice: |
00:31:03 |
Oh, those little scamps, |
00:31:07 |
They're waiting for dad. |
00:31:09 |
They have a surprise for him. |
00:31:11 |
- I open the door. |
00:31:15 |
Wipe your feet. |
00:31:17 |
Did you wipe them? |
00:31:19 |
- And it's quiet. |
00:31:22 |
The apartment, very quiet. |
00:31:26 |
And the lights. |
00:31:28 |
Lights are on everywhere. |
00:31:31 |
A child's slipper. Just one. |
00:31:34 |
A large bath towel. |
00:31:36 |
On the floor. |
00:31:39 |
You call them. |
00:31:41 |
"Please let them answer". |
00:31:44 |
The emergency phone |
00:31:47 |
- On the left. |
00:31:49 |
The cord's torn out, the receiver's |
00:31:54 |
- And... There it is! |
00:31:56 |
There! |
00:31:58 |
It opens. |
00:32:06 |
A panda. |
00:32:08 |
A big stuffed panda. |
00:32:10 |
Your daughter's favorite. |
00:32:13 |
It's a broken wine bottle. |
00:32:15 |
All is not lost. |
00:32:18 |
And here they are! |
00:32:22 |
No blood. She was strangled! |
00:32:24 |
You open the bedroom, and there, |
00:32:29 |
...is your wife. |
00:32:31 |
You want to yell, to run, |
00:32:34 |
You stand like pillar of salt. |
00:32:36 |
Over their bodies. |
00:32:38 |
- He's nuts. Nuts. |
00:32:41 |
You hear someone behind you. |
00:32:43 |
Who could it be? |
00:32:46 |
It's that same Chechen |
00:32:50 |
With the same knife. |
00:32:52 |
He slowly, methodically |
00:32:57 |
pulls back your head, |
00:33:00 |
takes that cold, sharp blade |
00:33:10 |
You, Harvard, will crawl |
00:33:14 |
With your last breath... |
00:33:17 |
You don't understand why he did it! |
00:33:21 |
He did it because we're |
00:33:22 |
just trophies to them! |
00:33:24 |
We're not humans, we're trophies! |
00:33:33 |
I change my vote. The killer is guilty. |
00:33:45 |
Good for you! |
00:33:48 |
And good for your mom, too. |
00:33:52 |
Smart. Lively. |
00:33:56 |
Imaginative. And truthful. |
00:34:05 |
There you go. |
00:34:08 |
Six - six. |
00:34:12 |
Very interesting. |
00:35:08 |
Why are you looking at me? |
00:35:11 |
I don't know... |
00:35:14 |
He's impressionable. |
00:35:18 |
He's sick. |
00:35:21 |
- Doctor... |
00:35:24 |
It's not... |
00:35:26 |
...food poisoning... |
00:35:31 |
It's nervous regurgitation. |
00:35:34 |
Give him some water. |
00:35:49 |
** scene-change ** |
00:36:23 |
- Are you OK? |
00:36:33 |
Yes. Yes... |
00:36:53 |
"The City Wolves". |
00:36:55 |
Season seven finale. |
00:36:57 |
That's right. I watched it. |
00:37:00 |
Every Monday through Thursday at 9:35 pm |
00:37:04 |
I'm glad. |
00:37:06 |
Thank you. |
00:37:19 |
Don't shoot! |
00:37:23 |
Everyone back! Back! |
00:37:27 |
Stay back, I said! |
00:37:29 |
Don't shoot! Stay where you are! |
00:37:34 |
Quiet! |
00:37:36 |
Quiet. |
00:37:38 |
Follow the car! |
00:37:41 |
Any wounded? |
00:37:44 |
- No, nobody. |
00:37:48 |
Umar. |
00:37:50 |
Hey, Umar. |
00:37:52 |
Is that you? |
00:37:54 |
It's me, uncle Volodya. |
00:37:57 |
Calm down. Don't be afraid. |
00:38:01 |
Get up. |
00:38:05 |
I'm uncle Volodya. |
00:38:09 |
Get up. |
00:38:10 |
Calm down, calm down. |
00:38:14 |
Umar. |
00:38:16 |
Umar. |
00:38:21 |
Calm down. |
00:38:24 |
Thank God I found you. |
00:38:27 |
Everything's OK now. |
00:38:52 |
Don't be afraid, it's me. |
00:38:55 |
Lord... |
00:38:58 |
You see, we have new lights, |
00:39:02 |
It's freezing. |
00:39:05 |
The wiring can't take it. |
00:39:09 |
Don't worry, |
00:39:12 |
Fine. |
00:39:22 |
- Here it is. |
00:39:24 |
I think I understand: |
00:39:28 |
When he gave his statement |
00:39:32 |
the building where |
00:39:35 |
But in court he gave |
00:39:40 |
Yes, he said... Ow! |
00:39:42 |
Sorry. |
00:39:43 |
He said that |
00:39:46 |
he went to his daughter's |
00:39:50 |
And stayed. |
00:39:53 |
That's right. |
00:39:55 |
He said he went there |
00:39:58 |
But the murder |
00:40:00 |
and his change of address |
00:40:03 |
Yes. |
00:40:05 |
But the daughter's birthday |
00:40:08 |
is in March. |
00:40:09 |
- Some light, please. |
00:40:13 |
And what does all this mean? |
00:40:16 |
Light. |
00:40:17 |
I'll explain. |
00:40:20 |
to bring me some information about |
00:40:25 |
It's a huge project, |
00:40:30 |
One square meter |
00:40:33 |
costs at least 4000 dollars. |
00:40:36 |
All the apartments are sold. |
00:40:38 |
But the building where the murder happened |
00:40:43 |
they plan to build a wing |
00:40:48 |
The construction schedule is firm. |
00:40:50 |
And? |
00:40:52 |
Now imagine you have to |
00:40:55 |
where people have paid millions |
00:40:58 |
But two old jerks |
00:41:02 |
won't let you start construction. |
00:41:05 |
It's a public building. |
00:41:08 |
The late officer stayed |
00:41:12 |
because it had been military housing |
00:41:16 |
But the military didn't have any other |
00:41:19 |
And the stubborn old party worker, |
00:41:22 |
wouldn't leave |
00:41:25 |
because he demanded an equally good |
00:41:29 |
In cases like that the job is done |
00:41:33 |
They send lawyers, building agents. |
00:41:37 |
They call themselves |
00:41:40 |
but really they're just crooks. |
00:41:43 |
And these thugs go after |
00:41:47 |
who fought against them in the war. |
00:41:50 |
And after the old communist |
00:41:52 |
who has no idea |
00:41:55 |
And so they cook up a |
00:42:00 |
They start surveillance. |
00:42:03 |
Study the relationships. |
00:42:06 |
See how they all interact. |
00:42:09 |
And wait for their moment. |
00:42:12 |
As a result: |
00:42:13 |
One person is killed, |
00:42:16 |
another, who did not kill anyone, |
00:42:19 |
is sent to prison, |
00:42:22 |
the third runs off to his daughter's |
00:42:26 |
And within a few days is living there... |
00:42:31 |
...permanently. |
00:42:35 |
It was... |
00:42:37 |
...a very lucrative scheme. |
00:42:39 |
So... |
00:42:42 |
...you're saying it was a |
00:42:47 |
Looks that way. |
00:42:49 |
But that's horrible! |
00:42:54 |
Well... |
00:42:57 |
...when millions of dollars |
00:43:02 |
...the difference between persuasion... |
00:43:05 |
...and execution... |
00:43:09 |
...disappears. |
00:43:10 |
How do you know all this? |
00:43:21 |
I say, how do you know all this? |
00:43:28 |
People talk. |
00:43:31 |
Pass the candle, please. |
00:43:33 |
Over here. |
00:43:37 |
So, you just told us |
00:43:44 |
...and what now? |
00:43:46 |
I'm convinced that the boy |
00:43:50 |
did not kill his father. |
00:43:53 |
I vote. |
00:43:55 |
Not guilty. |
00:43:59 |
Back to seven -five. |
00:44:04 |
I'll admit that your wild theory, |
00:44:08 |
But you're forgetting the other witness, |
00:44:13 |
Her windows are across from |
00:44:17 |
And she testified that she saw |
00:44:22 |
"The father hit the boy in the face, |
00:44:26 |
...the Chechen grabbed a knife |
00:44:29 |
...into the chest of the officer, Volodya". |
00:44:33 |
She had no reason to give |
00:44:36 |
Nobody wanted to tear down her building. |
00:44:39 |
Don't trust her! That woman |
00:44:43 |
She demonstrated |
00:44:47 |
Yes? |
00:44:49 |
Before I went to med school |
00:44:53 |
I saw lots of knife wounds. |
00:44:56 |
How could a kid who's |
00:45:02 |
How could he stab him |
00:45:06 |
What is this, a Bollywood movie? |
00:45:09 |
It's nonsense. |
00:45:13 |
It's just ridiculous. Listen... |
00:45:16 |
...what're you babbling about? |
00:45:19 |
I don't get it. A "Bollywood movie"? |
00:45:23 |
I've never been an orderly. |
00:45:27 |
...how a person can stab someone |
00:45:34 |
Want me to show you? |
00:45:36 |
Do you? |
00:45:40 |
Go ahead, if you can... |
00:45:42 |
- You want me to? |
00:45:46 |
All right. |
00:45:47 |
Look. |
00:45:53 |
Come here. |
00:45:55 |
Come here. |
00:45:57 |
How did he do it? I'll show you. |
00:46:00 |
Come here. There. |
00:46:03 |
Where...? |
00:46:05 |
Come here. |
00:46:10 |
How'd he do it? Watch. |
00:46:13 |
Come here. Watch. Watch. |
00:46:23 |
There. Like that. |
00:46:31 |
Stop. |
00:46:33 |
Am I shorter than you? |
00:46:34 |
Shorter by a head? Well? Am l? |
00:46:38 |
Shorter, right? |
00:46:43 |
Bollywood, you say? |
00:46:46 |
How could he do it? |
00:46:51 |
I'll show you. |
00:46:53 |
I'll show you how he could do it. |
00:47:02 |
His father hit him. |
00:47:08 |
Insulted him and hit him. |
00:47:13 |
I'll kill you! |
00:47:27 |
What was that? |
00:47:30 |
Is it blood? |
00:47:39 |
The bird... |
00:47:41 |
...pooped. |
00:47:45 |
Let me have the knife. |
00:47:50 |
You know? |
00:47:53 |
The boy grew up in a land where |
00:48:02 |
Anyone who's ever used |
00:48:07 |
you have to strike from below. |
00:48:09 |
It's always unpredictable. |
00:48:13 |
and always hard to defend against. |
00:48:17 |
What are you...? |
00:48:21 |
Then, to be sure the knife |
00:48:24 |
reaches the heart, |
00:48:28 |
...you must strike with power, |
00:48:35 |
Hey, stop... |
00:48:36 |
You're a surgeon. |
00:48:39 |
Yes, a surgeon. Can't you tell? |
00:48:42 |
A knife... |
00:48:45 |
...Iike any other weapon, |
00:48:49 |
is a form of culture. |
00:49:27 |
Sorry... |
00:49:28 |
...I learned it when I was a kid, |
00:49:32 |
Sorry. |
00:49:34 |
Very interesting. |
00:49:42 |
I change my decision. |
00:49:44 |
Oh Lord, I'm blind. |
00:50:07 |
I can't talk now. |
00:50:12 |
They're still deliberating. |
00:50:14 |
Can you imagine? |
00:50:16 |
All night. Imagine that... |
00:50:18 |
Got some real go-getters. |
00:50:22 |
Since our wiring is totally shot |
00:50:27 |
it's left over from a school dance. |
00:50:30 |
- A karaoke party... |
00:50:34 |
If you did your job, |
00:50:36 |
You'd be at a disco or a |
00:50:40 |
I propose we vote. |
00:50:44 |
The gentleman builder is right, |
00:50:48 |
I think the kid is not guilty. |
00:50:51 |
Please raise your hand if you |
00:50:59 |
One. Two. |
00:51:01 |
Three. |
00:51:04 |
Please raise your hand if |
00:51:09 |
One, two, three, |
00:51:11 |
four, five six, seven, eight. |
00:51:17 |
And you? |
00:51:20 |
Sorry. |
00:51:21 |
Are you...? |
00:51:24 |
- How do you vote? |
00:51:27 |
You said you change your mind. |
00:51:33 |
One second. |
00:51:36 |
Pardon me, but do you recall |
00:51:42 |
Ah, when you...? |
00:51:46 |
Thank you very much. |
00:51:48 |
Yes, I definitely change my mind. |
00:51:52 |
And vote that the accused |
00:51:57 |
You won't change again? |
00:52:00 |
What do you mean? |
00:52:03 |
Based on principle. |
00:52:05 |
Thanks to principles like that |
00:52:07 |
we'll wake up one day |
00:52:10 |
surrounded by green berets |
00:52:14 |
and foreign speech. |
00:52:17 |
I don't understand why |
00:52:21 |
You changed your mind |
00:52:24 |
No, pal, not like you did. |
00:52:26 |
He just described a very clear plan, |
00:52:30 |
It's one criminal scheme. |
00:52:32 |
It's not just one. |
00:52:36 |
What scheme? |
00:52:38 |
When the big fish don't |
00:52:43 |
who have to get by |
00:52:47 |
By their own rules. |
00:52:49 |
It's like that everywhere. |
00:52:51 |
In construction, in hospitals, |
00:52:54 |
and in cemeteries. |
00:52:55 |
What do cemeteries |
00:52:59 |
Have you ever buried anyone? |
00:53:02 |
Me? |
00:53:04 |
Yes, I have. |
00:53:09 |
Two years ago. |
00:53:13 |
Who was she? |
00:53:16 |
A Rottweiler. |
00:53:18 |
That's not a name. |
00:53:22 |
I don't know how they bury dogs |
00:53:25 |
but I do know how we see people off |
00:53:28 |
I've been a cemetery director for 8 years. |
00:53:33 |
You're burying a loved one. |
00:53:37 |
You go to the graveyard. |
00:53:40 |
- Like this. |
00:53:42 |
- That's mom. |
00:53:44 |
My mom's there. |
00:53:46 |
- Well, it's... |
00:53:49 |
The final farewell, relatives. |
00:53:52 |
And some old lady standing nearby. |
00:53:55 |
She looks into the grave |
00:53:58 |
They say "What is it?" |
00:54:02 |
How can that be? |
00:54:04 |
What can they do? You can't |
00:54:09 |
And the old granny whispers advice. |
00:54:11 |
They go to the head gravedigger, |
00:54:16 |
They say: "Sir, there's water in there. |
00:54:20 |
He gives them some line |
00:54:24 |
and he shovels the liquid |
00:54:26 |
But it runs back in. They're in shock. |
00:54:29 |
The old lady tugs at someone's sleeve |
00:54:34 |
that's completely dry. |
00:54:37 |
And pristine. |
00:54:38 |
Now here's the interesting part. |
00:54:41 |
The relatives ask the digger, |
00:54:44 |
"Listen is there any way |
00:54:48 |
"Are you crazy?" |
00:54:50 |
They're burying someone there |
00:54:53 |
No way. All the paperwork's done" |
00:54:57 |
They get on their knees, in tears; |
00:55:02 |
Just tell us how much". |
00:55:04 |
The rest is easy. |
00:55:07 |
For you, 2000 bucks. |
00:55:11 |
For someone else, 500. If they're poor |
00:55:16 |
They swap stones. |
00:55:20 |
The family leaves. |
00:55:25 |
They pull out the plastic sheet from |
00:55:29 |
and in 1 5 minutes it's dry. |
00:55:33 |
And the diggers are ready |
00:55:38 |
That's it. |
00:55:50 |
I'm glad we cremated |
00:55:58 |
Very interesting. |
00:56:05 |
Why are you looking at me? |
00:56:10 |
Is it different where you work? |
00:56:16 |
Everyone's in on it. Everyone. |
00:56:19 |
In their own way. |
00:56:22 |
Right, friend? |
00:56:27 |
Rolex? |
00:56:28 |
Yeah. |
00:56:31 |
Expensive. |
00:56:35 |
Well, yeah. |
00:56:36 |
On your cemetery pay? |
00:56:40 |
Yes... |
00:56:44 |
...on my cemetery pay. I won't lie |
00:56:48 |
But I also used that cemetery pay |
00:56:51 |
to restore the chapel. |
00:56:54 |
And I feed the bums who |
00:56:57 |
They have to eat somewhere. |
00:57:00 |
And I built a school in the town |
00:57:07 |
It has a gym... come visit, |
00:57:10 |
And we don't have monstrosities, |
00:57:13 |
My pipes are underground, |
00:57:16 |
There's a computer lab with |
00:57:21 |
Local teachers, all with |
00:57:26 |
We have a bus to bring kids |
00:57:29 |
And take them home, of course. |
00:57:31 |
So they don't have time |
00:57:36 |
And if you ask |
00:57:40 |
"Where'd the money to build this |
00:57:47 |
They couldn't care less where |
00:57:53 |
as long as the school stays |
00:57:56 |
So I use money from the dead |
00:58:00 |
Since nobody else is going to. |
00:58:12 |
In short, the Chechen is not guilty. |
00:58:17 |
Still, can you explain to me, |
00:58:20 |
an almost sane person, |
00:58:24 |
who is not part of any scheme, |
00:58:26 |
testified in court |
00:58:29 |
killed the Russian officer |
00:58:32 |
I know why. |
00:58:34 |
You can yell at me. |
00:58:39 |
- It was jealousy. |
00:58:43 |
Jealousy, |
00:58:46 |
She didn't hear the boy, |
00:58:50 |
She didn't see anything either |
00:58:54 |
At best, she saw some shadows, |
00:58:58 |
She didn't see anything. |
00:59:00 |
She was convinced that it was the boy |
00:59:03 |
because she wanted |
00:59:06 |
the worst in him. |
00:59:09 |
Why? |
00:59:12 |
Jealousy. |
00:59:13 |
Terrible, |
00:59:15 |
senseless, female jealousy. |
00:59:17 |
Look at these photos. |
00:59:19 |
She showed them in court. |
00:59:22 |
To prove that she knew the victim. |
00:59:26 |
Here's a photo of them at a party. |
00:59:29 |
Her, the deceased, and his wife. |
00:59:31 |
Now here's one... |
00:59:35 |
...of her, him, and someone's arm. |
00:59:38 |
It's his wife's arm. |
00:59:40 |
Why did she need to go |
00:59:45 |
so it only shows her |
00:59:47 |
Cutting out the wife. |
00:59:50 |
This is a photo of her dream. |
00:59:53 |
What happens next is very simple: |
00:59:57 |
A single woman, |
00:59:58 |
childless, who dreams of finally |
01:00:03 |
She likes the man from across the street, |
01:00:07 |
She writes him in Chechnya, |
01:00:11 |
- Can I see? |
01:00:13 |
And that she's sorry, |
01:00:17 |
True or not, |
01:00:21 |
It was jealousy. |
01:00:23 |
She engineered his divorce. |
01:00:26 |
That was it! |
01:00:28 |
No more obstacles. |
01:00:32 |
All she had to do was |
01:00:35 |
The return of her beloved. |
01:00:38 |
And he arrives, but not alone. |
01:00:40 |
He's with a nasty, filthy |
01:00:44 |
who can hardly speak Russian. |
01:00:46 |
Remember, she said she asked him |
01:00:52 |
And he just replied |
01:00:54 |
that he planned to live with the kid |
01:00:58 |
That was it. All her hopes, ruined. |
01:01:01 |
But she kept it up. |
01:01:03 |
Remember, she said she invited him over. |
01:01:06 |
With the boy. For her birthday. |
01:01:08 |
She made dinner, bought sweets, |
01:01:13 |
Later she discovered |
01:01:16 |
from next to where |
01:01:21 |
And she tried to convince him |
01:01:25 |
Eventually she admitted in court |
01:01:28 |
and forgot. |
01:01:33 |
But, at the time, she mentions |
01:01:35 |
in front of a combat vet |
01:01:39 |
She must have known |
01:01:42 |
And did happen, of course. |
01:01:44 |
The man hears that the kid |
01:01:49 |
And he loses control of himself. |
01:01:52 |
He smacks the boy, but she's silent. |
01:01:54 |
And when his nose bleeds |
01:01:57 |
she leaps to his defense |
01:02:01 |
Or rather, he's guilty, |
01:02:04 |
Because children are weaker, |
01:02:12 |
God! |
01:02:16 |
She didn't lie. |
01:02:18 |
She wanted to believe |
01:02:21 |
the murderer was the boy |
01:02:25 |
and no one else. |
01:02:28 |
Jealousy. |
01:02:32 |
Senseless, cruel, |
01:02:34 |
blind, instinctive |
01:02:39 |
female jealousy. |
01:02:44 |
That's it. |
01:02:47 |
Right there. |
01:02:49 |
She found the money later, |
01:02:56 |
I live with my son. |
01:02:58 |
He's twenty now, but back then, in"91 |
01:03:03 |
In 1 990 my wife left me. |
01:03:08 |
She ran off with a guy from the States. |
01:03:12 |
The kid was upset, of course, |
01:03:17 |
on a long trip, and that |
01:03:20 |
My mom looked after him. |
01:03:24 |
I had started driving a cab, |
01:03:30 |
Didn't really think about my family. |
01:03:33 |
Women are no problem for a cabbie. |
01:03:36 |
One day... |
01:03:38 |
...I started talking to this woman. |
01:03:42 |
We went out a couple of times, |
01:03:47 |
I didn't need much from her: |
01:03:51 |
Meals, laundry, take the kid to school. |
01:03:56 |
Kolya. Little Nikolai. |
01:04:01 |
For the life of me, I can't remember |
01:04:10 |
She began to tell me things |
01:04:13 |
...that he was lazy, |
01:04:17 |
I call him over and ask: |
01:04:20 |
He looks at me, smiling, |
01:04:26 |
I punished him. |
01:04:31 |
One day I'd had enough, |
01:04:36 |
but I just snapped. |
01:04:39 |
I busted into his room |
01:04:42 |
dragged him out of bed, |
01:04:45 |
She's quiet. |
01:04:48 |
She screams. |
01:04:50 |
"Murderer! Murderer! What are you doing?! |
01:04:55 |
And it started. |
01:04:58 |
I'd beat him... |
01:05:01 |
She'd see the blood and scream. |
01:05:04 |
It was brutal. |
01:05:08 |
And my boy, it was as if |
01:05:13 |
He stopped crying. |
01:05:16 |
blink over and over, but not cry. |
01:05:18 |
I punch him. |
01:05:22 |
And he keeps blinking and smiling. |
01:05:27 |
Blinking and smiling. |
01:05:33 |
One night I woke up. |
01:05:39 |
I heard water running. |
01:05:41 |
I go to the bathroom, |
01:05:44 |
He had pissed his bed. |
01:05:47 |
That kid... |
01:05:49 |
He sat in the corner |
01:05:52 |
Looking at me and smiling. |
01:05:55 |
Blinking and smiling. |
01:06:01 |
It was like he was always guilty. |
01:06:04 |
That look, and that smile. |
01:06:07 |
And I was right in a way, |
01:06:09 |
But in my soul, deep down... |
01:06:13 |
It was like someone made me |
01:06:18 |
Then she had a baby, also a boy. |
01:06:21 |
He was about four. |
01:06:25 |
I gave him a little smack. |
01:06:27 |
And bam! |
01:06:31 |
I barely got away. She threw an iron, |
01:06:39 |
I could slug my own son, |
01:06:41 |
but I just barely touched hers, |
01:06:50 |
She and the kid went to |
01:06:59 |
I was working nights. |
01:07:01 |
I had already left the building |
01:07:05 |
It was like someone grabbed me |
01:07:09 |
I saw a light in the window. |
01:07:13 |
I look all over, can't find him. |
01:07:15 |
I hear a rustling in the closet. |
01:07:18 |
I open the closet. |
01:07:20 |
And he's sitting there. |
01:07:25 |
And blinking. |
01:07:29 |
I say: "Son, what are you doing?" |
01:07:33 |
I hold him. He holds me tight. |
01:07:35 |
He looks at me, smiling and blinking, |
01:07:41 |
I say: "Son, what's that?" |
01:07:44 |
And I take his hand. |
01:07:53 |
And he's holding a noose. |
01:07:59 |
A noose he made from my belt. |
01:08:09 |
I don't know... |
01:08:12 |
...what he saw on my face. |
01:08:14 |
But he grabbed me, hugged me, |
01:08:19 |
And whispered: |
01:08:23 |
"Papa, don't, don't". |
01:08:27 |
"Don't, papa, don't". |
01:08:31 |
Smiling and saying: "Papa, don't". |
01:08:58 |
Well... |
01:09:00 |
... I vote... |
01:09:03 |
...the kid is not guilty. |
01:09:05 |
Write it down. |
01:09:07 |
Yes, you know, |
01:09:08 |
that was very persuasive. |
01:09:13 |
I agree, the boy is not guilty. |
01:09:16 |
- Let's vote. |
01:09:18 |
Who thinks he is not guilty, |
01:09:24 |
- Thank God. |
01:09:28 |
It's unanimous, he's not guilty. |
01:09:31 |
Wait. Let's write it down. |
01:09:35 |
Wait, please. Wait. |
01:09:38 |
Just wait. |
01:09:42 |
I haven't voted yet. |
01:09:44 |
- Well, I hope you'll join us. |
01:09:49 |
I think |
01:09:52 |
he's guilty. |
01:09:55 |
Eleven for "not guilty" |
01:09:59 |
- Listen! |
01:10:03 |
- These artists... |
01:10:07 |
- Come on... |
01:10:09 |
We only hurt the ones we love... |
01:10:18 |
I knew from the first minute |
01:10:20 |
that he was innocent. |
01:10:24 |
Professional experience. |
01:10:26 |
I agree with all the explanations |
01:10:30 |
The old man was obviously scared. |
01:10:33 |
And the woman... |
01:10:36 |
She wears glasses. And she claimed |
01:10:40 |
She had to put on her glasses |
01:10:44 |
It's not realistic. |
01:10:46 |
And the boy, well, he's from the Caucasus. |
01:10:51 |
I worked there a few times, |
01:10:55 |
He wouldn't yell "I'll kill you!", |
01:10:58 |
And he wouldn't make up |
01:11:04 |
The rest is obvious. |
01:11:08 |
Arranged by people |
01:11:10 |
who really need the kid |
01:11:14 |
We saw that. We proved that |
01:11:17 |
Right? |
01:11:18 |
But as soon as |
01:11:22 |
we reach that verdict, |
01:11:26 |
Of course they will. And? |
01:11:28 |
- That's great. |
01:11:31 |
Yes, thank God he's not a murderer. |
01:11:34 |
Then what? Why did you |
01:11:39 |
I don't understand at all. |
01:11:41 |
I have ceased to understand anything. |
01:11:46 |
I just don't understand anymore. |
01:11:48 |
After all we've gone through. |
01:11:51 |
And when... I'm sorry. |
01:11:53 |
And you... What is this? |
01:11:55 |
We've accomplished a great thing, |
01:11:59 |
We've established the truth. |
01:12:01 |
I can say one thing for sure. |
01:12:03 |
He'll live longer in prison, |
01:12:08 |
Very interesting. |
01:12:10 |
If he gets out now, he won't go to |
01:12:15 |
He has nothing, nobody, understand? |
01:12:18 |
He'll look for the killers. |
01:12:20 |
Also, if we acquit him now, |
01:12:24 |
it will automatically trigger |
01:12:29 |
The men who killed his father |
01:12:32 |
will be on guard, |
01:12:35 |
He'll look for them. |
01:12:37 |
And they'll look for him, |
01:12:42 |
But they know where he is. |
01:12:44 |
So our decision, instead of sending |
01:12:49 |
will be his death warrant. |
01:12:52 |
And they'll kill him crudely, horribly. |
01:12:56 |
Like a dog, with a sharpened screwdriver... |
01:12:59 |
And nobody will look for him. |
01:13:02 |
They'll find him 8 or 1 0 months later |
01:13:07 |
And that's it. |
01:13:09 |
There are people in the courtroom |
01:13:13 |
following every step of the trial. |
01:13:17 |
I can smell it. |
01:13:21 |
Understand? |
01:13:22 |
- An artist's instinct |
01:13:24 |
An artist's. |
01:13:27 |
Yes, an artist's. |
01:13:28 |
What if he hangs himself in prison? |
01:13:33 |
How do we know what'll |
01:13:36 |
How will he act? |
01:13:43 |
Well, then, that's his fate... |
01:13:48 |
...if he hangs himself. |
01:13:51 |
But I'll tell you one thing for sure. |
01:13:53 |
He'll live longer |
01:13:58 |
OK, then what do you suggest? |
01:14:03 |
Are you proposing we let |
01:14:06 |
while the criminals go free? |
01:14:08 |
- Exactly. |
01:14:10 |
Hide him away in prison: |
01:14:15 |
His home was torn down. |
01:14:19 |
We'll hire lawyers. |
01:14:23 |
We'll go to the prosecutor. |
01:14:26 |
And tell them what we know. |
01:14:30 |
Then, when they're locked up, |
01:14:35 |
And then he'll be free and safe. |
01:14:37 |
You'll excuse me, but, these lawyers, |
01:14:41 |
these professional people, |
01:14:44 |
Who's going to handle all of that? |
01:14:50 |
Who? What do you mean, who? |
01:14:52 |
Who? |
01:14:53 |
We will. Who else? |
01:14:56 |
Us? |
01:14:58 |
Who else has any use |
01:15:01 |
for a poor Chechen boy who |
01:15:06 |
and was accused of killing his father? |
01:15:08 |
Who's going to handle it? |
01:15:31 |
I'm a cab driver. Not an investigator. |
01:15:36 |
I understand, of course, but... |
01:15:40 |
... I don't know. |
01:15:44 |
I don't know, I used to have contacts |
01:15:49 |
But that was 1 00 years ago, |
01:15:53 |
And I'm supposed to go |
01:15:56 |
It's a complicated project. |
01:16:00 |
I have 850 employees to think about. |
01:16:03 |
What do you think? |
01:16:06 |
while there's an innocent man |
01:16:15 |
The 21 st, 22nd... |
01:16:18 |
...and the 20, yes. |
01:16:20 |
I for example have four operations |
01:16:25 |
On the 21 st, the 23rd, |
01:16:29 |
Should I cancel them all? |
01:16:33 |
OK, gentlemen. |
01:16:36 |
Let's say, purely hypothetically, |
01:16:40 |
that, say I could do it, but how? |
01:16:43 |
It's a very serious job. I'd need... |
01:16:45 |
I'd need a ton of time. |
01:16:49 |
I'm working day and night. |
01:16:51 |
The show's called "Planet Good." |
01:16:55 |
OK, it's clear that we'd |
01:16:59 |
A 3-month tour. |
01:17:03 |
Listen, my dear, kind friends. |
01:17:06 |
We've done a great thing. |
01:17:11 |
One who's a stranger to us, |
01:17:14 |
We've fulfilled our duty as jurors. |
01:17:16 |
The rest is up to other official organs. |
01:17:19 |
Don't start an amateur investigation. |
01:17:22 |
There are, after all, laws! |
01:17:25 |
What is it? Have you all lost it? |
01:17:29 |
You want to stick around till morning? |
01:17:33 |
I have to be at the airport |
01:17:37 |
My girlfriend's flying in from Dubai, |
01:17:41 |
She's 21. It's been 2 months. |
01:17:44 |
Are you out of your minds? |
01:17:47 |
I started to work out |
01:17:50 |
She has tits like melons. |
01:17:52 |
I haven't seen her for 2 months. |
01:17:57 |
Six feet one. |
01:17:59 |
Chocolate brown nipples. Like this. |
01:18:02 |
Lips like Angelina Jolie. Green eyes... |
01:18:05 |
Don't get me started on her ass, |
01:18:10 |
They laugh at me at the cemetery. |
01:18:14 |
"Julie, darling, dear. |
01:18:17 |
You're all that I desire. |
01:18:21 |
...and fire." |
01:18:24 |
And I have to bang her every half hour. |
01:18:28 |
21 years old. |
01:18:29 |
I can't sleep. Listen, |
01:18:34 |
Like I was 1 5. |
01:18:37 |
Television... Understand? |
01:18:40 |
I'm sick of this meeting. |
01:18:43 |
- Calm down. |
01:18:45 |
- Let's make a decision. |
01:18:47 |
Drink it yourself. |
01:18:49 |
Let's do something. |
01:18:54 |
What's so funny, eh? |
01:18:59 |
See that pipe? |
01:19:01 |
- What's that... |
01:19:04 |
- How many years? |
01:19:05 |
- How many more to come? |
01:19:08 |
Another40. |
01:19:09 |
And? What? What? |
01:19:11 |
Everything's like that. Everything. |
01:19:14 |
We come. We see. We judge. |
01:19:18 |
We drink. We talk in circles. |
01:19:21 |
And everything's like that. |
01:19:42 |
In other words, |
01:19:44 |
I have a suggestion. |
01:19:47 |
If even now, |
01:19:51 |
you still vote to find |
01:19:54 |
I'll join you. Sound good? |
01:19:58 |
Wait a second. Wait. Wait. |
01:20:03 |
And you'll definitely vote not guilty |
01:20:08 |
if we all do? |
01:20:12 |
I gave my word. |
01:20:13 |
Well, you know, the word of an artist... |
01:20:18 |
Fine. |
01:20:20 |
Don't like the word of an artist, |
01:20:26 |
Ex-officer, right? |
01:20:33 |
No such thing as a Russian ex-offi... |
01:21:00 |
Let's vote. Who votes to find... |
01:21:04 |
...the kid not guilty, raise your hand. |
01:21:11 |
- We're voting for not guilty. |
01:21:20 |
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, |
01:21:23 |
... 1 0, 1 1... |
01:21:32 |
... 1 2. |
01:21:54 |
"Not Guilty". |
01:22:13 |
It's still a better place. |
01:22:17 |
No, it hasn't worked out yet. |
01:22:24 |
Don't leave without me. |
01:22:42 |
Would you recognize them? |
01:22:45 |
Of course. I'll never forget them. |
01:23:04 |
We'll find them. |
01:23:05 |
We'll find them. I promise. |
01:23:11 |
What was your father's name? |
01:23:12 |
Ruslan. |
01:23:17 |
- And your other one? |
01:23:24 |
My name's Nikolai. |
01:23:27 |
Call me Uncle Nikolai. |
01:23:30 |
If you want. |
01:23:35 |
Let's get out of here. Let's go. |
01:25:47 |
So it's like this. |
01:25:51 |
If you want to fly away, then fly. |
01:25:54 |
The coast is clear. |
01:25:58 |
But make the decision |
01:26:01 |
all by yourself. |
01:26:04 |
Nobody will do it for you. |
01:26:10 |
It's been an honor. |
01:27:22 |
"TH E LAW lS ALL POWERFUL |
01:27:25 |
BUT WHAT CAN BE DONE WHEN MERCY |
01:27:30 |
B. TOSlA |