National Geographic Video Mysteries of Mankind
|
00:00:03 |
The earth does not easily yield |
00:00:07 |
Yet around the world scientists |
00:00:10 |
the compelling story |
00:00:13 |
It is a saga that blends the rigors |
00:00:16 |
with the romance of a detective story. |
00:00:25 |
We have only traces that hint |
00:00:27 |
and how they may have lived. |
00:00:31 |
It is like a gigantic puzzle with |
00:00:38 |
Today, biological scientists may |
00:00:43 |
but they all agree that evolution |
00:00:47 |
Animal studies now shed light |
00:00:51 |
became an upright walker |
00:00:54 |
and how it may have confronted |
00:01:08 |
Once barely noticeable |
00:01:10 |
humans would come to |
00:01:14 |
The tool, mother of all inventions, |
00:01:16 |
was a key to our success. |
00:01:31 |
Tools chipped from stone helped |
00:01:35 |
Now new tools help us |
00:01:39 |
we may have traveled along the way. |
00:01:43 |
Much of our current knowledge |
00:01:44 |
our understanding of who we are |
00:01:48 |
has come about only |
00:01:56 |
Can we reconstruct the past? |
00:01:59 |
Can long silent voices be summoned |
00:02:04 |
Join us as we probe |
00:02:52 |
By nature mammals are |
00:02:56 |
We humans are the most curious of all. |
00:02:59 |
And perhaps nothing arouses |
00:03:02 |
more than the intriguing question |
00:03:05 |
What about the cavemen? |
00:03:07 |
Caveman? |
00:03:10 |
A caveman. |
00:03:11 |
At the close of the 16th century |
00:03:14 |
All the world's a stage, and |
00:03:19 |
no one had any concept of the |
00:03:24 |
Today we yearn to know just |
00:03:27 |
in this greatest of dramas. |
00:03:29 |
When did they appear on the stage |
00:03:41 |
The story is elusive at best, |
00:03:44 |
like peering into mists that float |
00:03:51 |
Here and there through a dusky veil |
00:03:54 |
we think we catch a fleeting echo |
00:03:58 |
feel primordial eyes watching us |
00:04:04 |
A thread of kinship surges within us. |
00:04:07 |
Then, just as we grasp at a clue, |
00:04:11 |
the phantom voices melt away. |
00:04:21 |
In the early 1900s the scientific |
00:04:25 |
of mankind was in Asia. |
00:04:29 |
Then, in 1924, |
00:04:31 |
South African anatomist Raymond Dart |
00:04:34 |
was brought a skull workmen had found |
00:04:38 |
Dart outraged the scientific community |
00:04:43 |
apelike child |
00:04:44 |
was a hominid a member |
00:04:48 |
And, he said, |
00:04:53 |
Dart named the species |
00:04:57 |
southern ape of Africa. |
00:05:02 |
For more than a decade |
00:05:06 |
was paleontologist Robert Broom. |
00:05:09 |
Dart was finally vindicated |
00:05:13 |
discovered an assortment of |
00:05:22 |
Africa's Great Rift Valley has been |
00:05:24 |
geologically active |
00:05:28 |
an ideal setting for the burial |
00:05:33 |
here, Olduvai Gorge would become known |
00:05:38 |
because of two maverick scientists. |
00:05:43 |
Coming here in the 1930s, |
00:05:47 |
undertook one of |
00:05:49 |
in the history of anthropology. |
00:05:54 |
What particularly excited the Leakeys |
00:05:57 |
was the presence |
00:06:00 |
scattered across the eroded landscape |
00:06:04 |
Their passionate dream: |
00:06:08 |
who fashioned these tools to find |
00:06:13 |
It would be nearly a quarter |
00:06:15 |
before their single-minded |
00:06:19 |
The year was 1959. |
00:06:23 |
We appeared to have got |
00:06:25 |
Here at last was a man or |
00:06:29 |
apparently the earliest known man |
00:06:33 |
It would turn out to be a |
00:06:36 |
and not a true human, |
00:06:40 |
an australopithecine. |
00:06:43 |
And yet surely, like us, |
00:06:48 |
wobbled his way onto two upright legs, |
00:06:56 |
Then in the way of all flesh, he died. |
00:07:03 |
The boy died near the edge |
00:07:06 |
The skeleton is missing, |
00:07:07 |
perhaps washed away or destroyed |
00:07:11 |
Fortunately, |
00:07:15 |
Over the centuries water |
00:07:16 |
soluble minerals turned bone to stone |
00:07:19 |
as layer upon layer of deposits buried |
00:07:25 |
Some layers were volcanic ash laid down |
00:07:30 |
Gradual geological uplift typical |
00:07:34 |
and subsequent erosion brought |
00:07:40 |
The odds of finding a hominid fossil |
00:07:49 |
Because the Leakey's fossil was found |
00:07:53 |
it could be accurately dated. |
00:07:55 |
Volcanic ash contains radioactive |
00:07:59 |
into argon gas |
00:08:03 |
Human evolution was then believed |
00:08:05 |
to begin no more |
00:08:08 |
Yet here was |
00:08:12 |
The scientific world was stunned. |
00:08:17 |
Today, the addition of lasers |
00:08:20 |
enables scientists to date minuscule |
00:08:25 |
A single grain of ash, |
00:08:27 |
seen magnified here many thousands |
00:08:30 |
can produce a date much more |
00:08:41 |
The name and age of |
00:08:43 |
about how the creature actually lived. |
00:08:45 |
But perhaps the behavior |
00:08:50 |
Charles Darwin wrote that we are most |
00:08:54 |
But at that time no one knew how |
00:08:59 |
The answer would come from |
00:09:02 |
the test tubes of molecular biologists. |
00:09:08 |
Twenty years ago Dr. Vincent Sarich |
00:09:11 |
and his colleagues at the University |
00:09:14 |
were among a small group of scientists |
00:09:18 |
and test tubes instead of fossils. |
00:09:22 |
Sarich's group compared a blood |
00:09:27 |
including humans, |
00:09:30 |
from a common ancestor. |
00:09:36 |
The dates differed radically |
00:09:41 |
Among the great apes, |
00:09:45 |
the line that led to orangutans |
00:09:48 |
from a common ancestor. |
00:09:50 |
The evidence suggests gorillas |
00:09:54 |
According to Sarich, |
00:09:57 |
may have diverged as recently as four |
00:10:02 |
Such a recent divergence |
00:10:05 |
for many scientists to accept. |
00:10:07 |
Laymen were equally reluctant |
00:10:11 |
There is still a very strong |
00:10:16 |
at human beings in an evolutionary |
00:10:21 |
Because we want to |
00:10:24 |
We don't want to see ourselves |
00:10:27 |
as having any non-human |
00:10:32 |
There are significant differences |
00:10:35 |
We are essentially hairless |
00:10:37 |
Oh, he likes the beard. |
00:10:40 |
We are habitually upright walkers, |
00:10:42 |
we have a much larger brain, |
00:10:44 |
and we have the gift |
00:10:48 |
But genetically humans and |
00:10:53 |
Chimps may even be more closely related |
00:11:01 |
In 1960 Louis Leakey, |
00:11:05 |
sent a young woman into the field |
00:11:11 |
Jane Goodall's 27-year old study has |
00:11:15 |
and confirms Leakey's conviction that |
00:11:19 |
about the behavior of early humans. |
00:11:26 |
Understanding of chimp behavior today |
00:11:29 |
helps us to understand the way in which |
00:11:35 |
Because I think it makes sense |
00:11:38 |
by the modern chimpanzee |
00:11:42 |
was probably present |
00:11:45 |
And if it was present in the common |
00:11:56 |
A mechanical leopard was instrumental |
00:12:00 |
with chimpanzees conducted |
00:12:02 |
from the University of Amsterdam. |
00:12:05 |
Anthropologists have |
00:12:08 |
our ancestors defended |
00:12:12 |
How could such small creatures, |
00:12:14 |
not yet intelligent enough to make |
00:12:20 |
Leopards are natural predators |
00:12:23 |
Here, as the chimps attack, |
00:12:25 |
we catch a glimpse |
00:12:27 |
having left the safety of the trees, |
00:12:30 |
may have first met the challenges |
00:12:55 |
Once the leopard is decapitated, |
00:12:58 |
the chimp may not comprehend |
00:13:01 |
but it clearly knows the enemy |
00:13:10 |
If a chimpanzee has the intelligence |
00:13:14 |
it seems likely our early ancestors |
00:13:23 |
The chimpanzee has never |
00:13:27 |
Why did we? |
00:13:29 |
Upright walking is so fundamental |
00:13:32 |
and yet it is one of the crucial ways |
00:13:34 |
we are set apart |
00:13:37 |
When did our ancestors take that first |
00:13:42 |
to brave the vast African landscapes? |
00:13:53 |
Important answers would be found in |
00:13:59 |
Here, in 1974, |
00:14:01 |
an international expedition |
00:14:05 |
headed out to |
00:14:15 |
Co leader of the team, |
00:14:18 |
describes himself as superstitious. |
00:14:21 |
After two frustrating months |
00:14:25 |
he woke up one morning feeling lucky |
00:14:31 |
Later that very day |
00:14:32 |
the team discovered bones |
00:14:39 |
at the time the oldest, |
00:14:50 |
To anthropologists |
00:14:53 |
lucky to recover a tooth |
00:14:57 |
this 40% complete skeleton |
00:15:01 |
Nicknamed Lucy, |
00:15:02 |
she quickly became the object |
00:15:07 |
What is most exceptional |
00:15:11 |
as complete as Lucy |
00:15:14 |
we as anthropologists can glean |
00:15:17 |
For example, looking at |
00:15:20 |
which is only about |
00:15:22 |
we know that she was no taller |
00:15:26 |
Now that brings up the question |
00:15:30 |
If we look at the state of development |
00:15:34 |
for example, of the third molar |
00:15:37 |
it is fully erupted and |
00:15:39 |
So that relative to modern humans, |
00:15:41 |
she was an adult when she died. |
00:15:44 |
We're able to tell from |
00:15:47 |
of the hip socket, for example, |
00:15:49 |
that she probably only weighed |
00:15:53 |
From the size of the brain case, |
00:15:56 |
there is enough |
00:15:59 |
to suggest to us |
00:16:02 |
about one fourth the size |
00:16:08 |
Historically, large brains have been |
00:16:13 |
In the 20s when Raymond Dart suggested |
00:16:18 |
he had only a skull to work with. |
00:16:20 |
Here was a significant portion |
00:16:23 |
with some very ape like features |
00:16:29 |
Lucy had an ape like brain, |
00:16:34 |
and teeth both ape and human like |
00:16:39 |
Yet clearly she was a hominid, |
00:16:47 |
Returning to Hadar the following year, |
00:16:49 |
the team combed the slopes hoping |
00:16:54 |
They never dreamed they would find |
00:16:58 |
But the Johanson luck proved even |
00:17:04 |
We have the femur and |
00:17:11 |
They had come across the |
00:17:14 |
possibly members of the same band. |
00:17:17 |
They may have all perished together |
00:17:23 |
The fossils from Hadar |
00:17:26 |
represent from 35 to 65 individuals. |
00:17:30 |
Based on the abundant evidence, |
00:17:32 |
Johanson and |
00:17:35 |
in announcing an entirely new species. |
00:17:40 |
They called it |
00:17:44 |
and put forth |
00:17:47 |
that it is the common ancestor |
00:17:50 |
who eventually died out, |
00:17:52 |
as well as the line |
00:18:01 |
In the laboratory fragments |
00:18:04 |
from several males were combined |
00:18:09 |
by Johanson's colleague, Dr. Tim White. |
00:18:13 |
After initial discovery and analysis |
00:18:15 |
scientists rarely work |
00:18:20 |
In fact, |
00:18:20 |
the fossils are usually returned |
00:18:24 |
But these durable casts |
00:18:25 |
are exact replicas |
00:18:35 |
In Alexandria, Virginia, |
00:18:37 |
the composite skull begins |
00:18:41 |
in the hands of anthropologist |
00:18:49 |
Gurche has been fascinated with |
00:18:53 |
Today he combines the talents |
00:18:56 |
with those of a master sculptor. |
00:18:59 |
His workroom is a cross |
00:19:02 |
and a scientific laboratory. |
00:19:11 |
Placing the eyes |
00:19:14 |
I base the position of the eyes |
00:19:18 |
but there's also often a mystical side |
00:19:21 |
That is often the moment when I begin |
00:19:25 |
by the thing I'm working on |
00:19:29 |
of clay and plaster, |
00:19:34 |
What I really want to do is get |
00:19:37 |
and having the scientific data |
00:19:41 |
makes it much more rewarding for me |
00:19:43 |
because I can believe |
00:19:45 |
I can believe that the face |
00:19:46 |
in front of me is very much like |
00:19:48 |
of the individual that it |
00:19:57 |
The really fascinating thing |
00:19:59 |
with Australopithecines is |
00:20:02 |
on the line between being human |
00:20:05 |
You have a lot of features |
00:20:07 |
and yet it's in the process |
00:20:15 |
The reconstruction will take |
00:20:19 |
It is painstaking, |
00:20:20 |
arduous work that often continues |
00:20:30 |
I'd really like to be able |
00:20:32 |
for this kind of |
00:20:34 |
Unfortunately, it's not. |
00:20:37 |
It's as good as it can be |
00:20:39 |
in time and coming face to face |
00:21:00 |
The end result is often |
00:21:03 |
I'm basing the restoration on |
00:21:07 |
that I'm getting from the bony anatomy |
00:21:09 |
and the cumulative effect |
00:21:18 |
A face long lost to the tides of time |
00:21:21 |
emerges out of plaster and clay. |
00:21:25 |
We come face to face with one of |
00:21:30 |
across a chasm of three million years. |
00:21:45 |
More than half a million years |
00:21:48 |
and more than a thousand miles away, |
00:21:52 |
spewing ash across |
00:21:56 |
Then a moment was frozen in time. |
00:22:01 |
An amazing sequence of |
00:22:05 |
in the pageant of prehistory. |
00:22:08 |
Soon after the eruption the rain |
00:22:13 |
Then three hominids, |
00:22:14 |
perhaps of the same species as Lucy, |
00:22:18 |
Their footprints left an impression |
00:22:22 |
Only because the sun then came out did |
00:22:27 |
And only because continued eruptions |
00:22:32 |
were the traces entombed more than |
00:22:39 |
Today this area, |
00:22:40 |
not far from Olduvai Gorge in |
00:22:47 |
Here, in 1978, |
00:22:52 |
finds what is one of the most |
00:22:55 |
of all time the very footprints |
00:23:00 |
since the eruption of |
00:23:05 |
Dr. Leakey and her team begin |
00:23:08 |
of removing the cement hard rock. |
00:23:17 |
To Dr. Leakey the prints |
00:23:22 |
They tell a vivid story |
00:23:26 |
The track of footprints that |
00:23:30 |
was a truly remarkable find |
00:23:34 |
It's a trail left by three people |
00:23:37 |
who walked across a flat expanse |
00:23:40 |
three and a half million years ago. |
00:23:43 |
We can say they were relatively short. |
00:23:47 |
We can estimate that their height was |
00:23:53 |
We can say they had |
00:23:58 |
One assumes they were |
00:24:01 |
They are so evenly spaced, the tracks, |
00:24:06 |
always left foot for left foot |
00:24:10 |
that it may, for all we know, |
00:24:15 |
The emotional impact of the footprints |
00:24:19 |
but scientifically they arouse debate: |
00:24:23 |
Were these creatures related to Lucy, |
00:24:26 |
and could their upright walk so long |
00:24:34 |
Tim White helped excavate |
00:24:38 |
Now, to answer some of |
00:24:41 |
he has devised an experiment. |
00:24:44 |
With our closest living relative, |
00:24:46 |
he walks across an expanse of wet sand. |
00:24:49 |
Its consistency is roughly the same |
00:24:59 |
Here we have my footprint |
00:25:02 |
and the big toe in line with |
00:25:06 |
The chimpanzee's footprint is here and |
00:25:09 |
We see the chimpanzee's toe |
00:25:13 |
whereas the human toe is |
00:25:16 |
The human foot also has |
00:25:20 |
The chimpanzee foot and |
00:25:23 |
And at Laetoli we have evidence from |
00:25:27 |
of a large toe in line with the rest |
00:25:31 |
and a strong heel strike. |
00:25:33 |
In other words, |
00:25:34 |
the human pattern has been established |
00:25:37 |
in Tanzania with these early hominids. |
00:25:44 |
Some scientists feel that only by |
00:25:48 |
can we know how Lucy and our |
00:25:55 |
At the state University |
00:25:58 |
a team led by anatomists Randall Susman |
00:26:02 |
videotapes the movements |
00:26:05 |
They have also extensively |
00:26:08 |
Come on. |
00:26:11 |
Electrodes implanted in the arm |
00:26:14 |
send signals to monitoring equipment. |
00:26:17 |
Clothing holds the transmitter |
00:26:22 |
That's good bipedalism. Keep him going. |
00:26:25 |
On their screen Susman and |
00:26:30 |
of the electrical output |
00:26:34 |
One intriguing finding: |
00:26:36 |
The hip muscles used by apes |
00:26:39 |
of the same ways as human hip muscles |
00:26:43 |
So the transition from tree dweller |
00:26:47 |
may have been relatively simple. |
00:26:49 |
The pattern of muscle usage |
00:26:54 |
Good boy. |
00:26:59 |
But Susman and Stern, unlike Johanson, |
00:27:03 |
believe that these ancestors |
00:27:07 |
but more like an ape when it walks |
00:27:11 |
They maintain that those creatures, |
00:27:13 |
still spent much time in the trees |
00:27:16 |
and had not yet fully adapted |
00:27:22 |
In earlier days, |
00:27:23 |
anthropologists compared and |
00:27:27 |
but could only ponder questions |
00:27:31 |
Today they can directly address |
00:27:33 |
some of the fundamental issues |
00:27:37 |
How did Lucy and the others live? |
00:27:39 |
Where did they sleep? |
00:27:41 |
What did they eat? |
00:27:48 |
In the line of other Australopithecines |
00:27:53 |
there were smaller creatures |
00:27:56 |
and robust ones |
00:28:02 |
The fossil teeth themselves hold clues |
00:28:08 |
Thousands or millions of years later, |
00:28:15 |
Let's see if |
00:28:17 |
Dr. Fred Grine, also at Stony Brook, |
00:28:19 |
studies diet, using a scanning electron |
00:28:25 |
Different foods leave distinctively |
00:28:29 |
Comparing the two patterns |
00:28:32 |
and robust australopithecine side |
00:28:34 |
it becomes quite evident |
00:28:36 |
that the wear patterns |
00:28:38 |
and that, therefore, |
00:28:40 |
the foods they would have eaten would |
00:28:42 |
The scratches and |
00:28:45 |
on a gracile Australopithecine molar |
00:28:49 |
by soft foods such as soft fruits |
00:28:52 |
whereas the pitting which characterizes |
00:28:55 |
a robust Australopithecine molar |
00:28:58 |
by hard food objects such as seeds |
00:29:04 |
Shrouded in myth since their discovery |
00:29:07 |
Australopithecines were |
00:29:10 |
as blood thirsty killer apes. |
00:29:14 |
It now seems far more |
00:29:17 |
who should be seen |
00:29:20 |
in the human evolutionary drama. |
00:29:23 |
Robust Australopithecines flourished |
00:29:28 |
then disappeared an apparent |
00:29:35 |
It is possible they lost out |
00:29:38 |
more intelligent species |
00:29:43 |
a line that would eventually lead |
00:29:52 |
Like the remains of their predecessors |
00:29:54 |
the fossil bones of the tool users are |
00:29:58 |
in deposits formed along lake shores |
00:30:04 |
The areas around Lake Turkana |
00:30:06 |
in northern Kenya have a record |
00:30:08 |
and animal life that is |
00:30:21 |
Every week during the field season, |
00:30:23 |
a light plane from Nairobi brings |
00:30:27 |
son of Louis and Mark Leakey. |
00:30:32 |
Despite an early decision not to |
00:30:36 |
Richard's passion for |
00:30:39 |
For two decades he has been |
00:30:45 |
Over the years since 1968 the Turkana |
00:30:50 |
to fifteen thousand fossil remains. |
00:30:53 |
Most are animal, but amazingly |
00:30:59 |
Leakey has been called the "organizing |
00:31:04 |
He heads a team that scours |
00:31:07 |
for several months at a time. |
00:31:09 |
They cover every foot of |
00:31:15 |
Looking for new evidence in any |
00:31:18 |
In our field it's |
00:31:20 |
because every year there |
00:31:22 |
These vast areas of desert |
00:31:26 |
and every time it rains, |
00:31:28 |
there's a chance that something new |
00:31:29 |
will be exposed something new |
00:31:32 |
to tell us something that |
00:31:33 |
It's going to expose |
00:31:35 |
in our understanding of human origins. |
00:31:37 |
And it's really great fun |
00:31:39 |
on the desert realizing that although |
00:31:42 |
this year it will be different |
00:31:45 |
and something new must have |
00:31:48 |
It's simply a question of finding it. |
00:31:52 |
In 1984 a small piece |
00:31:55 |
It was immediately recognized as human |
00:32:02 |
With anatomist Alan Walker |
00:32:05 |
he went on to unearth a seemingly |
00:32:10 |
The rest of the skull |
00:32:13 |
and painstakingly glued together |
00:32:20 |
The bones were clearly those |
00:32:24 |
a species on the path |
00:32:30 |
The skeleton, a boy of about 12, |
00:32:33 |
was dated at more than a million |
00:32:36 |
Far more complete than even Lucy, |
00:32:39 |
it is one of the most remarkable finds |
00:32:44 |
The boy differs little |
00:32:46 |
in stature and body proportions. |
00:32:50 |
An artist imagines |
00:32:54 |
Richard Leakey reconstructs |
00:32:59 |
The area that he was living |
00:33:02 |
swampy ground near the lake edge. |
00:33:05 |
There was grassland; |
00:33:07 |
there were permanent rivers running |
00:33:10 |
Probably an enormous amount of |
00:33:13 |
carnivores, scavengers. |
00:33:15 |
I suppose one could visualize an area |
00:33:18 |
in East Africa today, |
00:33:19 |
teeming with wildlife ideal conditions |
00:33:23 |
I think it's remarkable |
00:33:26 |
But perhaps another aspect that is |
00:33:30 |
is that many people |
00:33:32 |
of human evolution have been able to |
00:33:35 |
On the basis that it was built |
00:33:39 |
just little bits and pieces. |
00:33:40 |
And who knows. |
00:33:42 |
Those little bits of |
00:33:44 |
To confront some of these people |
00:33:45 |
with a complete skeleton that is |
00:33:48 |
and is so obviously related to us. |
00:33:51 |
In a context where it's definitely one |
00:33:52 |
and a half million years or a little |
00:33:57 |
And I think many of the people who |
00:34:01 |
about creationism versus evolution are |
00:34:04 |
in the light of this discovery. |
00:34:11 |
A Homo erectus head would have |
00:34:15 |
It had a heavy brow ridge, |
00:34:21 |
It is very likely their skin was dark |
00:34:24 |
nature's protection against |
00:34:28 |
Some scientists believe Homo erectus |
00:34:33 |
In earlier times our ancestors, |
00:34:37 |
were probably accepted without fear |
00:34:41 |
But when they began to hunt, |
00:34:43 |
the other animals would sense them |
00:34:50 |
Exactly when hunting began may never |
00:34:54 |
But it is clear that the tools made |
00:34:56 |
by erectus were far more sophisticated |
00:35:06 |
Even the earliest and |
00:35:09 |
a momentous advance for humankind |
00:35:11 |
the first evidence of culture. |
00:35:15 |
And, as intelligence grew over time, |
00:35:17 |
tools became ever more refined |
00:35:38 |
Learning how tools |
00:35:41 |
provides a window into the behavior |
00:35:44 |
Dr. Nicholas Toth of Indiana University |
00:35:52 |
Many scientists had believed |
00:35:54 |
of the earliest toolmakers was to |
00:35:59 |
and that the chipped off flakes |
00:36:02 |
Toth's experimentation led him |
00:36:07 |
The razor sharp flakes, he believes, |
00:36:09 |
were often the tools our |
00:36:17 |
If you take a hard look |
00:36:19 |
we're very poor carnivores. |
00:36:21 |
We have small canines; |
00:36:24 |
we're not very strong; |
00:36:26 |
we don't look anything like |
00:36:28 |
And I think with |
00:36:31 |
you can butcher an animal |
00:36:34 |
to the size of an elephant |
00:36:52 |
Even hyenas will not tackle |
00:36:56 |
But with the simplest tools used |
00:37:00 |
an early hominid could get |
00:37:06 |
Almost completely fat, |
00:37:10 |
essential to a hominid roaming |
00:37:17 |
When an animal bone is butchered, |
00:37:18 |
the edge of the tool leaves cutmarks. |
00:37:23 |
Often ignored in the past, |
00:37:25 |
cutmarks are now recognized as vital |
00:37:31 |
They can tell us, for instance, |
00:37:36 |
which parts of these animals |
00:37:39 |
and ultimately they may reveal when |
00:37:46 |
In the past scientists often |
00:37:51 |
if tools were found nearby. |
00:37:54 |
Today they know many factors from the |
00:38:03 |
One factor not often considered came to |
00:38:08 |
by Dr. Kay Behrensmeyer. |
00:38:11 |
In Asia she had been puzzled |
00:38:14 |
on bones eight to |
00:38:17 |
long before hominids existed. |
00:38:19 |
Later, in Africa, |
00:38:21 |
she saw how bones frequently |
00:38:26 |
Could random trampling, she wondered, |
00:38:28 |
leave marks that could be confused |
00:38:35 |
Dr. Pat Shipman of |
00:38:38 |
has been experimenting |
00:38:42 |
She believes that |
00:38:45 |
and examining them microscopically, |
00:38:47 |
she and other can better define |
00:38:56 |
Into a scanning electron microscope, |
00:39:00 |
she inserts a gold coated cast |
00:39:07 |
Compared with regular microscopes, |
00:39:08 |
the SEM offers greater depth |
00:39:11 |
at three-dimensional structures. |
00:39:15 |
It seems likely that marks |
00:39:17 |
in sandy soil may remain open |
00:39:22 |
But for others, |
00:39:23 |
Shipman has found that |
00:39:26 |
are the fine lines within a groove. |
00:39:32 |
is the best way |
00:39:34 |
to a bone thousands or millions |
00:39:39 |
The problem for us today |
00:39:41 |
is to tease out of the past, |
00:39:46 |
the specialness of early hominids. |
00:39:50 |
And once we know where we started |
00:39:52 |
and what was important then, |
00:39:54 |
we may have a very different idea |
00:39:59 |
Homo erectus was the |
00:40:04 |
Sometime after a million years ago, |
00:40:07 |
and those of a number |
00:40:10 |
first appear in other tropical regions |
00:40:14 |
Some scientists believe that |
00:40:16 |
by then meat had become an |
00:40:20 |
With the addition |
00:40:22 |
this intelligent and curious creature |
00:40:26 |
to expand out to unknown lands. |
00:40:31 |
We know from preserved remains and |
00:40:36 |
Java and southern Europe. |
00:40:43 |
On the Sussex coast of England, |
00:40:45 |
quarry workers were the first |
00:40:50 |
It may hold answers to the life style |
00:40:53 |
after Homo erectus. |
00:40:58 |
About 350,000 years old, |
00:41:00 |
Boxgrove is |
00:41:04 |
It covers a hundred acres, |
00:41:05 |
and it contains vast numbers of tools |
00:41:08 |
and animal bones that |
00:41:14 |
Erectus probably never reached |
00:41:18 |
but his descendants did. |
00:41:20 |
They were the earliest form |
00:41:25 |
Here flags mark the locations |
00:41:28 |
or fragments have been found. |
00:41:32 |
Animal bones abound. |
00:41:34 |
Deer teeth. |
00:41:39 |
Part of the lower jaw of |
00:41:45 |
A large pelvic bone with cutmarks |
00:41:50 |
Yet strangely, |
00:41:57 |
So untouched is the site that if one |
00:42:02 |
here would sit an ancestor |
00:42:10 |
Nearby, what may have been that very |
00:42:16 |
for the first time in 350,000 years. |
00:42:20 |
Perhaps it was used to scrape wood, |
00:42:22 |
prepare a hide, or dig for roots |
00:42:26 |
It may have helped kill the deer |
00:42:30 |
But where is the maker of the tool? |
00:42:41 |
Once Boxgrove was a beach front, |
00:42:46 |
Why no people have been found remains |
00:42:50 |
in the human puzzle. |
00:42:56 |
These pre modern Homo sapiens |
00:43:01 |
but their exact relationship |
00:43:04 |
as well as to the more modern humans |
00:43:12 |
One of the most puzzling of these pre |
00:43:17 |
Some scientists think they were a short |
00:43:23 |
Indeed, the longest ongoing controversy |
00:43:26 |
in paleoanthropology has been |
00:43:31 |
But there are more questions |
00:43:34 |
We do know the Neanderthals |
00:43:37 |
so often portrayed by cartoonists. |
00:43:40 |
But one characteristic attributed |
00:43:44 |
They were cave people. |
00:43:51 |
At Kebara Cave in Israel, |
00:43:53 |
a Neanderthal excavation in run jointly |
00:44:01 |
When carefully studied, |
00:44:02 |
layers in a cave can tell a rich story. |
00:44:06 |
Too often in the past they were dug |
00:44:10 |
Thirty years ago Kebara was attacked |
00:44:14 |
Today, dental probes and fine brushes |
00:44:23 |
Each pail of dirt is screened for even |
00:44:29 |
Each piece will then be washed, |
00:44:36 |
By far the greatest number |
00:44:38 |
have been these well fashioned tools. |
00:44:42 |
Literally hundreds of thousands |
00:44:49 |
The leader of the Israeli team |
00:44:54 |
He has clear evidence that over |
00:44:57 |
Neanderthals repeatedly occupied |
00:45:02 |
What we can see here |
00:45:05 |
by the people around |
00:45:11 |
And this is one of |
00:45:14 |
that we can see these fireplaces |
00:45:16 |
which are built one on top |
00:45:18 |
and always at the same place |
00:45:23 |
They were either heating the area |
00:45:24 |
of the cave during wintertime |
00:45:29 |
And then when you still have |
00:45:31 |
spreading them |
00:45:34 |
One problem that we should always keep |
00:45:38 |
and we should not perhaps excavate |
00:45:43 |
because we have to preserve part of |
00:45:46 |
who will probably use better techniques |
00:45:51 |
And, therefore, we'll never know |
00:45:54 |
of what really happened everywhere. |
00:45:58 |
We do know Neanderthals camped |
00:46:02 |
or at least came here with food, |
00:46:04 |
perhaps huddling in groups around |
00:46:08 |
We also know some of them died here. |
00:46:15 |
Neanderthals were the first people |
00:46:19 |
This skeleton, |
00:46:20 |
except for the missing skull which |
00:46:24 |
is among the most |
00:46:31 |
What the meaning of burials was in the |
00:46:36 |
cannot be known for certain. |
00:46:39 |
But the fact that they buried |
00:46:41 |
to us in deep and meaningful ways. |
00:46:47 |
From Neanderthal excavations throughout |
00:46:51 |
a picture of how they lived |
00:46:54 |
Theirs was a non-settled existence. |
00:46:57 |
A socially organized people, |
00:47:00 |
as they moved from place to place |
00:47:04 |
Hardy and robust, they were probably |
00:47:10 |
They survived even in |
00:47:14 |
Whether they had language |
00:47:17 |
But surely, in some sophisticated way, |
00:47:20 |
they communicated with their own. |
00:47:26 |
Then about 30 to 40,000 years ago |
00:47:31 |
well-adapted people |
00:47:34 |
They may or may not have evolved |
00:47:39 |
If modern Homo sapiens evolved |
00:47:43 |
Neanderthals may have simply |
00:47:48 |
Anatomically much like us, |
00:47:50 |
these early modern humans stood |
00:47:53 |
everything we usually define as human. |
00:47:57 |
Farming and the rise of |
00:48:01 |
But these early modern humans were |
00:48:07 |
This rich record of the past |
00:48:08 |
ranks among the greatest artistic |
00:48:39 |
We know these people spread to every |
00:48:44 |
but where had they come from? |
00:48:50 |
One scientist at the British Museum |
00:48:54 |
thinks the answer has been found. |
00:48:57 |
Physical anthropologist |
00:49:01 |
The research on the origin of |
00:49:06 |
because it deals with the origins |
00:49:10 |
And my idea of an African origin |
00:49:14 |
I feel that modern people |
00:49:17 |
and then later on in other parts |
00:49:20 |
But there is also genetic data, |
00:49:22 |
and the genetic data also support |
00:49:26 |
of an African origin of modern people. |
00:49:29 |
At the University of Hawaii one of |
00:49:33 |
in this field investigates |
00:49:39 |
Dr. Becky Cann believes her research |
00:49:43 |
to the theory of an African origin. |
00:49:48 |
All humans who are alive today |
00:49:52 |
in their genes back to a single female |
00:49:55 |
who, we think, lived in Africa |
00:49:58 |
sometime perhaps |
00:50:03 |
Dr. Cann bases her theory on studies |
00:50:09 |
She traces backward in time one part |
00:50:11 |
of the DNA molecule that |
00:50:17 |
The genetic work is supplemented |
00:50:20 |
with interviews about |
00:50:24 |
Could I ask you about your maternal |
00:50:28 |
My grandmother was born |
00:50:33 |
Macau is the coast of China. |
00:50:36 |
Dr. Cann has studied Americans |
00:50:39 |
African, and Asian descent, |
00:50:42 |
as well as Australian Aborigines. |
00:50:46 |
By comparing small segments of DNA |
00:50:50 |
Dr. Cann assesses the similarities |
00:50:54 |
The more alike the DNA, |
00:50:56 |
the more closely related |
00:50:59 |
With a computer, |
00:51:00 |
Cann suggests different migration |
00:51:05 |
If she is right, modern humans, |
00:51:07 |
like earlier hominids, |
00:51:13 |
In Africa it seems that the evolution |
00:51:17 |
and from there |
00:51:20 |
So we're all very closely related. |
00:51:23 |
And that goes for |
00:51:26 |
Australian Aborigines, Eskimos, |
00:51:28 |
Europeans we all trace our origin |
00:51:30 |
and under the skin we are all Africans. |
00:51:33 |
Old concepts of |
00:51:37 |
But certainly we must consider |
00:51:41 |
is a fact of our evolution |
00:51:46 |
We are all time travelers together, |
00:51:49 |
the most recent players |
00:51:52 |
at least four million years ago. |
00:52:00 |
In the detective story |
00:52:02 |
we know in a broad sense |
00:52:05 |
But we know very little about |
00:52:09 |
There are too many fossils |
00:52:13 |
and too many gaps in time |
00:52:18 |
The science of anthropology is |
00:52:22 |
But as it moves forward, |
00:52:26 |
poses greater riddles. |
00:52:29 |
To begin filling |
00:52:31 |
the discovery |
00:52:35 |
New technologies will add other pieces |
00:52:40 |
But that is all we can expect |
00:52:44 |
Never can the entire picture be known. |
00:52:50 |
For scientists the excitement |
00:52:59 |
And as the rains come again next year |
00:53:02 |
they know that somewhere |
00:53:06 |
with a bit of luck, |
00:53:08 |
they will find new and |
00:53:12 |
to the ongoing drama of our human past. |